Jerry, sorry - but invoking "Hollywood" in any kind of conversation like this is very strange! It just has so little to do with anything....I enjoy a good movie here and there, and also enjoy a good Broadway play, but scapegoating a dancer or singer certainly does not help the debate.
As far as windfall profits, I don't remember discussing that.....so perhaps you made up an opinion for me? I appreciate it. However, since you believe in an "open market", I'm sure you will agree that actual tax subsidies given to oil companies by our government...when oil was $30 a barrel....to entice them to drill at those prices...should be discontinued. After all, in a free market why should you add billions to the billions (in profits).....that is a false economy.
Again, we are talking pretty much crap because we have an exaggerated sense of our own importance. The rest of the world could care less about whether we drill for more oil....which might come online in 5-10 years (and we are already doing so anyway).....
In my opinion, the current crisis has these and other aspects to it....
FIRST OF ALL, THERE IS NO SHORTAGE. If anyone here has stopped in empty gas stations or been unable to get home heating oil, let us know....please.
Ok, so hopefully we dispensed with that.....
1. The US Dollar is very weak - this is a fact and responsible for a LOT of the price run-up. It is basic common sense to understand that an oil producing country would rather have solid Euros or other currency than a dollar which is unstable. I just talked to someone who returned from a tour of Russia and Europe and he said vendors will not even accept US Dollars because they are scared of a drop in value before they cash them in!
2. Instability in the middle east - somewhat relates to or causes #1 above, but at the same time this causes some fear - which leads to more speculation, which leads to more fear, etc. - Heck, I will admit to making quite a lot of money myself on energy equities. Where did this money come from? Well, sadly from all of our pockets when we pay for gas and oil.
3. Excess speculation in the oil markets - evident to many experts. The price of Natural gas has doubled in the last year - let it remains almost 1/2 the price of fuel oil in many areas. Even LP is now cheaper than oil in many areas - heck, ELECTRIC is almost the same price as oil now. I may be wrong, but I will guess that heating oil will not be the (current) $5 and more when the actual heating season is upon us. Of course, some of that depends on policy and the election, etc.
In addition to the above, there are the intangibles which are somewhat related to the above - both the American people and folks all over the world KNOW that we have no energy policy and energy plan. This is a crisis of confidence...or lack thereof. The fact is that our "American stock" has declined greatly in most of the world over the last 7 years......this is not opinion, but fact. As to energy specifically, remember that this Prez is an oil man from texas and the VP is an oil man - remember that the Energy policy was made in Cheneys office in secret...meeting with Enron and most of the other oil and energy powers, and had almost nothing to do with conservation or renewables. Remember that large tax credits were passed for expensive SUV purchases....remember that GW asked us all to go shopping (not to sacrifice) in response to 9/11.
I could go on, but suffice it to say that Americans seem to have a very short memory! Just one year ago, stove sales were dried up........almost nothing.
While you cannot blame one man (GW) for every aspect of this crisis, it turns out that both his lack of leadership on ANY energy issue, and his being "owned" from the beginning by the oil and energy interests certainly did not help matters! In this case, it is/was BOTH a sin of omission and a sin of commission.