,
Pellet stoves will never be mainstream because there is too much daily feeding and maintenance involved. Sure we few owners don`t mind but we are a minority .
Also pellet stoves are space heaters and they suck at heating a house evenly.
There`s nothing easier and safer ,or more efficient , comfortable , and quiet than a central heating system.
After using a Napoleon pellet stove every season since installation in September 2008, and finally getting this 1959 brick/block bungalow sealed up adequately and with enough attic insulation, I can tell you for certain that the pellet stove heats this house a lot more quietly - and, in some particular ways, a lot more evenly- than my modern natural gas furnace.
Our pellet stove is located in a corner at one end of the house. The gas furnace is in a corner at the other end. The HVAC thermostat is in between the two, in a hallway in the center of the house.
The kitchen and laundry room are at the opposite end of the house from the pellet stove. (The furnace is in the laundry room.) The laundry room has no HVAC vent in it. Because the laundry room has no vent, and because the laundry room and the kitchen are at the far end of the house from the pellet stove, that area can be a bit chilly when outside temps are in the teens or single digits. The pilot light in the gas water heater throws off enough heat to keep the laundry room at a reasonable temperature, however, and when the water heater fires up, there's that many more BTU's in the laundry room. I solve the kitchen temperature gradient issue by cooking dinner.
As far as noise, we are in a bit of a different situation than most because our pellet stove is not in the room in which we sit to watch t.v.- it's one room over. Convection currents carry the heat into our living room and the bedrooms easily enough, and we aren't trying to hear the t.v. over the stove's convection blower.
I am so accustomed to the nuanced white noise of the stove's fan in the other room, that low, quiet hum, and the ever so slightly present tinkle of pellets falling into the pot, that on the rare occasion when the gas furnace does fire up, it sounds like a jumbo jet landing in the house. If it fires up overnight or early in the morning it wakes us up.
As far as even heating, we are lucky in that regard. Air sealing this old house as best we could and adding insulation in the attic really helped us hang onto the BTU's produced by the stove. I won't argue at you for a minute about the fact that the kitchen end of the house is cooler than the stove end of the house- but I will point out that the stove is producing heat and dumping BTU's into the house continuously. The furnace fires up, blasts heat into the house, and then waits for the house to cool down, the thermostat to drop, and does it all over again. And we have the thermostat programmed to fire the furnace at a one degree lag- so it's not like we are letting the house cool down by two or three degrees before the furnace fires up again.
After 5.5 years with the pellet stove, I find that I notice the "blast heat/cool down" disparity in heating evenness more than I notice the temperature falling off in the kitchen.
But that's just me- YMMV.
P.S. As far as safety, I wouldn't necessarily rank my gas furnace as safer than my pellet stove. We keep both cleaned and in good repair. If my pellet stove goes bonkers, I can threaten it with the fire extinguisher. I can empty the fire extinguisher onto/into it. I can throw the fire extinguisher at the pellet stove, throw the cat out of the window, and head for the nearest doorway with The Hubs and the 80 lbs. dog in tow.
If the gas furnace, fed by the gas lines over which I have no control, goes bonkers, I doubt I'll even know what happened. Threatening the gas furnace with a fire extinguisher sounds like a quick study in futility to me...
Last edited: