Some friends whose woodstove has expired have indicated an interest in a new efficient wood boiler, and tying it into their HW baseboard heat. I have a downdraft boiler myself and am completely happy with it, but for various reasons, I think a Garn in a nearby outbuilding might suit them especially well. I've seen various descriptions of Garn installs with a plate HX between the Garn and the heated spaces, where some of the heat zones are above the Garn. What I am wondering is: just as some do "solar drainback," could one do a system where at least the 2nd floor of the heated space did not rely on the boiler system to stay full of water at all times, and, rather, relied on pumping to get water and heat up there as needed? Seems as if it might simplify things- if it's suitable?
"Garn drainback" feasible?
- Thread starter pybyr
- Start date
-
Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.
We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.
We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil. -
Super Cedar firestarters 30% discount Use code Hearth2024 Click here
- Status
I can think of all sorts of problems, if they are concerned about freezing glycol would be the answer.
It can be done, we have done it many times.
The potential problem is when the tank or Garn is hot, and you are pumping up to a second floor, there is the potential to flash the water to steam in odd circumstances when the water returning to the tank might find itself under a slight vacuum.
This is very cool, but can make ungodly noise (always at 3am--in my case) but the subtle physics is kind of amazing. It can continue to induce flow after a circulator shuts off, sometimes even with a check valve. I thought it was a lot of fun and interesting, except it sounded like clanking steam lines.
At very least, there will be water noise, which is not always appreciated.
The potential problem is when the tank or Garn is hot, and you are pumping up to a second floor, there is the potential to flash the water to steam in odd circumstances when the water returning to the tank might find itself under a slight vacuum.
This is very cool, but can make ungodly noise (always at 3am--in my case) but the subtle physics is kind of amazing. It can continue to induce flow after a circulator shuts off, sometimes even with a check valve. I thought it was a lot of fun and interesting, except it sounded like clanking steam lines.
At very least, there will be water noise, which is not always appreciated.
Sounds like you are wanting to run a system non-pressurized? If so, in addition to the issues that Tom mentioned is the concern about 02 in the plumbing - and the potential for corrosion it induces... This is probably the biggest reason why the typical Garn install uses a heat exchanger - it allows the non-pressurized open Garn to work with a pressurized heating system. One can design a system that will work as an open system, essentially by eliminating all ferrous metal components, but it makes the design more difficult as many common parts may be harder to come by in copper or brass, and will cost a lot more...
Gooserider
Gooserider
- Status
Similar threads
