maple1
Minister of Fire
No doubt the Garn is a good rig with a good rep. But they are also very big. That prevented me from even considering one, no way I could get it into my basement. That's when separate boiler & storage becomes a consideration, much easier to adapt to a space. A pressurized boiler (Garn isn't) might also be easier to adapt to existing system. It would be somewhat of a trade-off though, pressurized = no heat exchangers needed, but expansion tanks would be necessary.
Sounds like poor performing heat pumps are a big part of the current issue, possibly from originally picking the wrong units for the application. Age may also be playing a part but we don't know what they are or how old. Or if the existing system was designed & installed properly to start with - could be lots of ducting heat loss too? There also seems to be a bit of a mish-mash of system work there now? Radiant (hot water) at least partially installed, and heat pumps (forced air)? Maybe the heat pumps were selected and put in primarily for a/c and heating with them was an afterthought?
Air to water heat pumps are also coming more into play, they should (hopefully) be seeing more advances the next year or two. So could also be part of a solution especially with in floor heating. Even with having a very good and efficient wood burning boiler/storage setup here, I am really loving the new mini-splits we put in in November. The older I get and more years go by, making fires & putting wood up (even though I enjoy going to the woods to do it) does become more of a chore every year - and I haven't had to bother making a fire on in over a month. We have two 15k btu/hr units - next power bill will tell a better story (we have a 2 month milling cycle), but so far they have added only around $30-40 each per month to it.
Sounds like poor performing heat pumps are a big part of the current issue, possibly from originally picking the wrong units for the application. Age may also be playing a part but we don't know what they are or how old. Or if the existing system was designed & installed properly to start with - could be lots of ducting heat loss too? There also seems to be a bit of a mish-mash of system work there now? Radiant (hot water) at least partially installed, and heat pumps (forced air)? Maybe the heat pumps were selected and put in primarily for a/c and heating with them was an afterthought?
Air to water heat pumps are also coming more into play, they should (hopefully) be seeing more advances the next year or two. So could also be part of a solution especially with in floor heating. Even with having a very good and efficient wood burning boiler/storage setup here, I am really loving the new mini-splits we put in in November. The older I get and more years go by, making fires & putting wood up (even though I enjoy going to the woods to do it) does become more of a chore every year - and I haven't had to bother making a fire on in over a month. We have two 15k btu/hr units - next power bill will tell a better story (we have a 2 month milling cycle), but so far they have added only around $30-40 each per month to it.