MissMac
Minister of Fire
Try testing the calibration of your moisture metre, if it has that function. On mine, there is a place to stick the prongs on the outside of the lid, and there's a small range of readings you're supposed to get when you do this. I test mine every year to make sure it's good for testing wood. Look in your manual or on google to see if you can test your calibration. Sounds like this might be the next step. I think your MM is off.