Performance is all a matter of perspective.
I have a Sirocco insert. It was professionally installed October 2020 at my house near Spokane WA .
The chimney is 27 feet of 6-inch double-wall, insulated metal liner inside the existing masonry chimney with an 8-inch square clay liner. Space between the new insulated metal liner and existing clay liner is blocked off only at the top with a sheet-metal plate that is sealed to the existing liner. The new insulated metal liner is topped-off with a standard chimney cap.
So far I have been burning Ponderosa Pine almost exclusively. Living in a Ponderosa Pine forest, it makes perfect sense to burn free Ponderosa Pine firewood.
My wood has been split, stacked, covered and drying for more than a year, and measures at 10 -15% moisture.
As most of you know, Ponderosa pine is a light softwood, and isn't loaded with BTUs. It burns up in a jiffy. Even so, a judiciously packed firebox (crammed full with as little free space as I can manage) will burn on low for 10 hours with no problem.
I grew up in a large super-drafty 1880's two-story farmhouse heated by an open fireplace in the living room and a woodstove in the kitchen. The vast quantities of firewood that those two consumed would be mind-blowing to most on this board. It was typical that a generous cord of white oak with a bit of Douglas Fir mixed-in to get the fire going, would go up the stacks in a single week. Mind you, this was in NW Oregon where temps below freezing were not encountered more than a few days each winter.
Heat output of this little Sirocco insert, and the niggardly amount of wood it burns, is absolutely astounding to me. I bought this insert to stick in a basement fireplace merely as an emergency heat source to keep the house from freezing up when the local utility goes into the inevitable FUBAR mode. (Another unavoidable feature of living in a pine forest . . .)
Anyway, my wife likes the fire so much that the Sirocco is running a whole lot more than I ever expected it would. Right now it is over 80F degrees down here in the 1200 foot daylight basement, and outside it is only about 30F. Upstairs it is much more temperate with the thermostat set at 69F. This house is a vintage 1972, poorly insulated, 3800 square-foot, monstrosity, with 16 foot ceilings upstairs, crummy insulation, and lotsa glass. Running the Sirocco down in the basement certainly cannot keep the entire house above 69 (let alone 80), on a colder winter day, but the gas furnace only come on now and then if a fire has been running all day.
Like I said, it is all a matter of persepctive - buying a Blaze King insert was one of the very few good decisions I've made in a long time