Stove Top Fan and other accessory recommendations?

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
  • Super Cedar firestarters 30% discount Use code Hearth2024 Click here

bobanne

New Member
Oct 15, 2024
34
WY, USA
Hey fellow wood stove enthusiasts!

We finally have our BK Ashford installed and are loving it. There are a few accessories that I've seen recommended and I wanted to get everyone's take on these.
1. Is it useful or decorative
2. Is there one you recommend
3. Are there other accessories you love using with your stove

First: The Stove Top Fan
Second: The water kettle
Third: The chimney thermometer

Thanks everyone!
 

Attachments

  • [Hearth.com] Stove Top Fan and other accessory recommendations?
    71CALwEgnbL._SL1500_.webp
    120.9 KB · Views: 3
  • [Hearth.com] Stove Top Fan and other accessory recommendations?
    81Wqe0whBDL._AC_SL1500_.webp
    119.8 KB · Views: 3
  • [Hearth.com] Stove Top Fan and other accessory recommendations?
    71s1BLJjOgL._AC_SX679_.webp
    56.2 KB · Views: 3
I'll go, since everyone seems a little shy right now.

EcoFans(heat powered stovetop mini fan)
I have one, after the first one died after giving several years of free assistive convection.
They ARE different.
My original was 3 blade, 5" width. It MOVED the air. I found it hard to imagine all those people thinking they were useless, toys, or cosmetic. I believe it got heat soaked, which will kill the peltier module...(electronics that make it work)
My new one this year is being 'tweaked'...It's a 4 blade 5" width. This one's designed for a Mr Buddy propane heater, but it's also a stovetop.
It's blades are terrible, barely push any air. I'm setting blades now, but honestly we haven't burned this year more than a handful of low burns so i can't tell you the final result.

HERE is a tip. Make sure the one you try has a Bi-Metal strip on the base. This is supposed to protect the module by lifting the foot off the stovetop if it gets too hot.

Here is a hack. You can buy modules off Ebay, Amazon for a dollar or two. Get a DVD/CD player(PC)at a thrift store for the motor. Use a chainsaw cylinder head for the heat sink. Buy aluminum fan blade off Amazon/ebay.
If you/someone can wire/solder you can make a multi-fan for a small cost.(Ecofans are high this time of year)

BONUS/ when the power is out, your ceiling fan, room fan isn't going to get warm air to the far areas without 120v. The Ecofan will stir the air.

THIS is important. YOUR stovetop temp determines the fan RPM. If YOUR specific stovetop only gets 340F, you are not going to get high CFM.
I have a sheet metal Fisher Grandpa Bear from '75?. When the stovetop temp clears over 624F, the fan wants to take flight. It roars, and You can feel circulation 15 feet away.(the old one, #1)

No brands, just recommend wider the better, and get a safety bimetal foot in yours. I bought the 'build your own' parts above, just no time yet to get to it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobanne
Kettle.
I would use a regular copper bottom tea kettle or coffee pot. Copper so it transfers effectively. It will also be soft, no scratch. Copper will not react/galvanize with the stove even when wet.
Cheap, rustic and functional.
My cast iron kettle doesn't like the plate metal used in my stovetop, with pitting and rust....so copper it is.

If I had a screaming potbelly stove, cast iron running wide open all day, it'd be perfect for the cast iron kettle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobanne
I'll go, since everyone seems a little shy right now.

EcoFans(heat powered stovetop mini fan)
I have one, after the first one died after giving several years of free assistive convection.
They ARE different.
My original was 3 blade, 5" width. It MOVED the air. I found it hard to imagine all those people thinking they were useless, toys, or cosmetic. I believe it got heat soaked, which will kill the peltier module...(electronics that make it work)
My new one this year is being 'tweaked'...It's a 4 blade 5" width. This one's designed for a Mr Buddy propane heater, but it's also a stovetop.
It's blades are terrible, barely push any air. I'm setting blades now, but honestly we haven't burned this year more than a handful of low burns so i can't tell you the final result.

HERE is a tip. Make sure the one you try has a Bi-Metal strip on the base. This is supposed to protect the module by lifting the foot off the stovetop if it gets too hot.

Here is a hack. You can buy modules off Ebay, Amazon for a dollar or two. Get a DVD/CD player(PC)at a thrift store for the motor. Use a chainsaw cylinder head for the heat sink. Buy aluminum fan blade off Amazon/ebay.
If you/someone can wire/solder you can make a multi-fan for a small cost.(Ecofans are high this time of year)

BONUS/ when the power is out, your ceiling fan, room fan isn't going to get warm air to the far areas without 120v. The Ecofan will stir the air.

THIS is important. YOUR stovetop temp determines the fan RPM. If YOUR specific stovetop only gets 340F, you are not going to get high CFM.
I have a sheet metal Fisher Grandpa Bear from '75?. When the stovetop temp clears over 624F, the fan wants to take flight. It roars, and You can feel circulation 15 feet away.(the old one, #1)

No brands, just recommend wider the better, and get a safety bimetal foot in yours. I bought the 'build your own' parts above, just no time yet to get to it.
Cool hack idea. I'd love to see it. What do you mean by modules?
 
I have the stovetop fan and it does move some air. However having a top -loading stove means I have accidentally whacked it a few times with a split of wood so the blades are bent and it wobbles. The blades are pretty easy to bend back but hard to get it perfect. So if you don't abuse it, it's a nice little fan.

I have a pipe probe thermometer (condar brand) and rely on it every time I load the stove to know when it's time to shut the bypass. Highly recommended and practically essential if you have double wall pipe.

The moose kettle seems cute but a bit silly. If you have humidity issues in the winter I'd think it better to chase after the drafts in your house and get them sealed up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobanne
I find a "kettle" helps, I have a custom square stainless water container on our insert most of the time, I can't believe how much water it will evaporate, around a gallon a day. However it has left a stain and some rust on the stove top so I'm not sure what I'll do this year on the new stove. Maybe just dry more we snow gear in the stove area.

Stove top fan is awesome, but I'm unsure that it actually does anything other than look neat. I would like a second one for stove #2, which one is best? Ours is off Amazon and seems pretty good.

Fire poker, I made a heavy duty one, I consider it essential.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobanne
Hey fellow wood stove enthusiasts!

We finally have our BK Ashford installed and are loving it. There are a few accessories that I've seen recommended and I wanted to get everyone's take on these.
1. Is it useful or decorative
2. Is there one you recommend
3. Are there other accessories you love using with your stove

First: The Stove Top Fan
Second: The water kettle
Third: The chimney thermometer

Thanks everyone!
You have the BK Ashford, just get the fan kit for it. I didn't have it for my first season with my Ashford and after installing and using it for the past couple of seasons it really helps move warm air (in my situation - everyone's is different).
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobanne