Good post.
One note on EPDM. You were lucky to have it maintain so long. Lower temps do allow EPDM to last for a reasonable life. It does tend to break down and the breakdown byproducts do affect copper tubing.
We have not seen this with other liner materials.
In full disclosure, we have seen some DHW hx failures due to corrosion, usually from the inside out. This seems to be due to pH issues.
We have subsequently shifted over to stainless steel hx for DHW.
One note on EPDM. You were lucky to have it maintain so long. Lower temps do allow EPDM to last for a reasonable life. It does tend to break down and the breakdown byproducts do affect copper tubing.
We have not seen this with other liner materials.
In full disclosure, we have seen some DHW hx failures due to corrosion, usually from the inside out. This seems to be due to pH issues.
We have subsequently shifted over to stainless steel hx for DHW.