- Feb 19, 2007
- 156
Part 6 of Mega-Query: Paint, N-S Wood Loading and Ash Pans
Hi all,
The above subhead lists the topics in this section of My Mega-Query: Which Woodstove to Get? series.
Please see this link for the specifications of the house, etc…, should you need to clarify something to answer the following questions. https://www.hearth.com/talk/threads/6812/ Thanks.
Painted (non-black colored) Steel Stoves—A Headache?
The Country Canyon ST310’s brochure says the following about paint:
"Your Country Stove may be painted in a variety of
colors with high-temperature stove paint to fit any
decor. Ask your dealer for details."
I must say, I’m a little nervous about this. Per the factory, there is black paint on the stoves to begin with, but I didn’t yet get to ask if that’s also just a spray-bombing raid, or some more permanent process.
The factory does not do the color (non-black) painting. Apparently the dealer does it. My fear is that the dealer will not be as anal as I would in removing finger oils, etc…, and the paint will peel in a season or two. I’m imagining how the stove will look in a couple of seasons—like a blue zebra or a blue leopard, with the black coming through?
I’m assuming blue (or any of the three colors offered) would be more difficult to keep looking nice than black, because if the black comes off, it probably wouldn’t be that noticeable.
Has anyone had any experience with non-black stove paint?
Has anyone had any experience painting a Quadra-Fire, Country, Lopi or ?
Again, though I’ve asked it elsewhere, is anyone aware of a steel, enameled stove, other than the Napolean or P.E., that is in this (large) size class?
North-South (N-S) Wood Loading
Despite Quadra-fire’s awkward wording, where they describe such loading as “front-to-back” (which to me connotes an East-West or parallel-to-the-stove’s-width orientation) I understand that they mean you can put the wood in perpendicular to the width of the stove, or N-S, as I’ve seen it referred to here.
This seems to have three advantages to me:
a) any falling logs (from over-full stacking for an overnight burn) will fall to the sides of the stove, as opposed to into the glass.
b) most stoves have a large amount of air coming in low, at the front, to “air wash” the glass, right? This would seem to feed oxygen equally to all the splits/rounds at once, in a N-S orientation, as opposed to feeding air to just the front or first log, in an E-W orientation.
c) If b), above, is correct, could this more even distribution of the air actually reduce the overnight burn duration significantly, such that I make my maximum burn too short to go all night?
d) As noted in the Quadra-fire literature, based on a), above, you can “toss the wood in”, without fear of it bouncing against the glass, making for easier loading and less bending-over time.
e) The Quad 5700 will accept a 24” log, per the brochure, presumably in an E-W loading orientation. But what will it accept, in an N-S loading? Could someone measure the depth of their firebox? (Please make that the “usable depth,” as there may be obstructions near the door which prohibit a full-length log from laying in there.
I know at least one person here is doing N-S loading in a P.E. Summit, and my friend Harry does it in his Hearthstone Mansfield.
Could owners of any of the stoves below supply the internal measurements for how long a log you can “toss” in, in a N-S loading orientation?
Country Canyon ST310
Lopi Liberty
Quadra-fire 5700
Napolean 1900
P.E. Summit “Classic”
Ash Removal—Are Ash Pans “Worth It?”
This feature is not a “deal breaker” for me, either way, so for those short on time, please skip to another section. I’m more curious here than concerned.
I’m only considering stoves with pedestal options, largely for aesthetic reasons, and because a few inches higher is a few less inches to bend over for loading and cleaning. In all but the Liberty Lopi’s case, the pedestal can accept an optional ash pan.
Almost everyone I’ve talked to doesn’t even use the ash pans when they have them, saying they’re either too difficult to fill or too small to mess with. My friend with the Mansfield just shovels it out, having disliked the ash pan after one use. Originally, I was thinking an ash pan was important, as I detest shoveling the ashes out of my “box of death” at the cottage, because it has a sand layer at the bottom, and it sucks trying to scoop the ash and leave the sand.
But the Lopi Liberty, as I say, doesn’t even have the ash pan as an option, (in pedestal configuration) and some of the stoves require you to remove a plug from the floor of the firebox, to fill the pan, as opposed to just opening a trap door, and that seems like a P.I.T.A. at best, dealing with a hot ash plug, if your are trying to remove ashes “on the fly” without letting the stove cool.
Thoughts on ash pans, anyone?
Thanks again,
Peter
>
Hi all,
The above subhead lists the topics in this section of My Mega-Query: Which Woodstove to Get? series.
Please see this link for the specifications of the house, etc…, should you need to clarify something to answer the following questions. https://www.hearth.com/talk/threads/6812/ Thanks.
Painted (non-black colored) Steel Stoves—A Headache?
The Country Canyon ST310’s brochure says the following about paint:
"Your Country Stove may be painted in a variety of
colors with high-temperature stove paint to fit any
decor. Ask your dealer for details."
I must say, I’m a little nervous about this. Per the factory, there is black paint on the stoves to begin with, but I didn’t yet get to ask if that’s also just a spray-bombing raid, or some more permanent process.
The factory does not do the color (non-black) painting. Apparently the dealer does it. My fear is that the dealer will not be as anal as I would in removing finger oils, etc…, and the paint will peel in a season or two. I’m imagining how the stove will look in a couple of seasons—like a blue zebra or a blue leopard, with the black coming through?
I’m assuming blue (or any of the three colors offered) would be more difficult to keep looking nice than black, because if the black comes off, it probably wouldn’t be that noticeable.
Has anyone had any experience with non-black stove paint?
Has anyone had any experience painting a Quadra-Fire, Country, Lopi or ?
Again, though I’ve asked it elsewhere, is anyone aware of a steel, enameled stove, other than the Napolean or P.E., that is in this (large) size class?
North-South (N-S) Wood Loading
Despite Quadra-fire’s awkward wording, where they describe such loading as “front-to-back” (which to me connotes an East-West or parallel-to-the-stove’s-width orientation) I understand that they mean you can put the wood in perpendicular to the width of the stove, or N-S, as I’ve seen it referred to here.
This seems to have three advantages to me:
a) any falling logs (from over-full stacking for an overnight burn) will fall to the sides of the stove, as opposed to into the glass.
b) most stoves have a large amount of air coming in low, at the front, to “air wash” the glass, right? This would seem to feed oxygen equally to all the splits/rounds at once, in a N-S orientation, as opposed to feeding air to just the front or first log, in an E-W orientation.
c) If b), above, is correct, could this more even distribution of the air actually reduce the overnight burn duration significantly, such that I make my maximum burn too short to go all night?
d) As noted in the Quadra-fire literature, based on a), above, you can “toss the wood in”, without fear of it bouncing against the glass, making for easier loading and less bending-over time.
e) The Quad 5700 will accept a 24” log, per the brochure, presumably in an E-W loading orientation. But what will it accept, in an N-S loading? Could someone measure the depth of their firebox? (Please make that the “usable depth,” as there may be obstructions near the door which prohibit a full-length log from laying in there.
I know at least one person here is doing N-S loading in a P.E. Summit, and my friend Harry does it in his Hearthstone Mansfield.
Could owners of any of the stoves below supply the internal measurements for how long a log you can “toss” in, in a N-S loading orientation?
Country Canyon ST310
Lopi Liberty
Quadra-fire 5700
Napolean 1900
P.E. Summit “Classic”
Ash Removal—Are Ash Pans “Worth It?”
This feature is not a “deal breaker” for me, either way, so for those short on time, please skip to another section. I’m more curious here than concerned.
I’m only considering stoves with pedestal options, largely for aesthetic reasons, and because a few inches higher is a few less inches to bend over for loading and cleaning. In all but the Liberty Lopi’s case, the pedestal can accept an optional ash pan.
Almost everyone I’ve talked to doesn’t even use the ash pans when they have them, saying they’re either too difficult to fill or too small to mess with. My friend with the Mansfield just shovels it out, having disliked the ash pan after one use. Originally, I was thinking an ash pan was important, as I detest shoveling the ashes out of my “box of death” at the cottage, because it has a sand layer at the bottom, and it sucks trying to scoop the ash and leave the sand.
But the Lopi Liberty, as I say, doesn’t even have the ash pan as an option, (in pedestal configuration) and some of the stoves require you to remove a plug from the floor of the firebox, to fill the pan, as opposed to just opening a trap door, and that seems like a P.I.T.A. at best, dealing with a hot ash plug, if your are trying to remove ashes “on the fly” without letting the stove cool.
Thoughts on ash pans, anyone?
Thanks again,
Peter
>