Newbie Question - Should I replace this stove? Is it safe to operate?

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

Cyxelsid

New Member
Jul 25, 2024
2
Cripple Creek, CO
OK, so I am a REAL newbie here... recovering city dweller moving out to the country. I have never owned or operated a wood stove, so I have a lot of learning to do.

This question may have already been asked, but I am up against a deadline in the purchase of a home with a wood stove, and I have to make a decision very soon (24 hours) on whether or not I need to ask the Seller of the house to pay for a new stove or not. I will peruse through the threads, but I thought I would try and save some time and ask a quick question.

We did the home inspection today, and the home inspector said he saw cracking/damage in the fireplace fire wall. According to the inspector, this could lead to "chimney damage or toxic fumes entering the home".

As you can see, there is a Mickey Mouse wiring job on the attached blower, I know that is going to have to be redone, obviously. Inspector also recommended the stove be thoroughly cleaned. (I will be looking for a thread on proper maintenance of a wood stove!)

The immediate question is this: Is the inspector being overly cautious or is this a real issue? If this is a real issue, then rather than play games with safety, I will just ask for concessions to replace the stove. If it is not that big of a deal, then I may not address this, as there are other items that need to be addressed as well. It is all about spreading limited resources as far as possible. But safety issues take first priority.

Any help would be appreciated.

Newbie Question - Should I replace this stove? Is it safe to operate?
Newbie Question - Should I replace this stove? Is it safe to operate?
 
OK, so I am a REAL newbie here... recovering city dweller moving out to the country. I have never owned or operated a wood stove, so I have a lot of learning to do.

This question may have already been asked, but I am up against a deadline in the purchase of a home with a wood stove, and I have to make a decision very soon (24 hours) on whether or not I need to ask the Seller of the house to pay for a new stove or not. I will peruse through the threads, but I thought I would try and save some time and ask a quick question.

We did the home inspection today, and the home inspector said he saw cracking/damage in the fireplace fire wall. According to the inspector, this could lead to "chimney damage or toxic fumes entering the home".

As you can see, there is a Mickey Mouse wiring job on the attached blower, I know that is going to have to be redone, obviously. Inspector also recommended the stove be thoroughly cleaned. (I will be looking for a thread on proper maintenance of a wood stove!)

The immediate question is this: Is the inspector being overly cautious or is this a real issue? If this is a real issue, then rather than play games with safety, I will just ask for concessions to replace the stove. If it is not that big of a deal, then I may not address this, as there are other items that need to be addressed as well. It is all about spreading limited resources as far as possible. But safety issues take first priority.

Any help would be appreciated.

View attachment 328551View attachment 328552
There is absolutely no way to know without a full on-site inspection sorry
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cyxelsid
That looks like a Consolidated Dutchwest. A good stove for the 80s, but there’s better out now. I’d see if the seller would give you a credit and you can find a stove that meets your needs. Worst they can say is no.
 
That is an old CDW, never a great stove to start with. Find something more modern, you'll appreciate your investment.
 
That is an old CDW, never a great stove to start with. Find something more modern, you'll appreciate your investment.
They actually were fantastic stoves for their day and can still work quite well
 
Totally disagree, which is allowed I believe. Their cat operation was not great, the door handles were questionable and when VC owned them at least, their support wasn't the best. Modern non cats and even new cat models are probably better for a person not familiar with that unit. Just my opinion...
 
Good advice, a steel stove is easier to use, burns clean but does need good dry seasoned wood like all stoves to work well.
 
Get the credit. Spend the time deciding which stove to buy that suits your needs. Don’t let the seller decide what to put in there.
 
Realize that the inspection report is for you to understand what issues you may face if you bought this house. It is not a repair list that the seller must resolve. All you can do is ask if they are willing to fix an issue or discount the price, it's all a negotiation. They can say yes, no, or something in between.
 
  • Like
Reactions: stoveliker