Need chainsaw advice...bigger or lighter?

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
  • Super Cedar firestarters 30% discount Use code Hearth2024 Click here
I bought the last 660 my dealer had 2 years ago and I dearly love this saw for the big wood! And the last 2 MS 260 Pros while I was at it! Should last me for what time I have left in this world...I have a old 056 myself...thought it was the greatest at one time....takes a healthy young man to run that sucker all day! We will see what happens with the re-release of the 441....
 
have a old 056 myself...thought it was the greatest at one time....takes a healthy young man to run that sucker all day!

It's a terrible saw really. I only keep my 056 because it's been in my family since new and it was made in the 70s. It's cut thousands of cords. And heated my parents house including the family farm and all the out buildings for many years. My Dad's almost 80 years old so now it's my saw. But compared to a modern saw it's junk.

I'm not a guy who keeps old stuff running for years and years. When it gets beat up it gets sold.
 
660 is a great saw, but I have heard nothing but great things about the new 661. A bigger saw always makes it easier when cutting big wood. I'm a fan of always going with the bigger saw if you have big wood to cut easier on everything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: StihlKicking
To answer the question "bigger or lighter?" I would answer yes. It really helps to have both if you can stand it. In my situation I would choose lighter if forced to. I can pick and choose smaller stuff if need be but since I have a big saw and a light saw I just cut whatever I want. I would look at 50cc saws for light saws and 70cc plus for big saws. In my humble opinion 60cc saws qualify as neither light or big.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ashful
60cc is the "one saw" compromise, and one could argue it's a decent compromise. I have a 85cc, 63cc, and a 35cc top handle saw, and find this is the ideal saw plan... if you don't mind having that sort of money tied up in saws. I cut with a guy who has a 75cc saw in is three-saw lineup, and find it's too small for big wood while too heavy for small wood, but we all have different preferences and stamina.

Two of my saws were pre-owned low-hours saws, because I try to be frugal, when it's not going to cost me time or frustration. If I were buying new today, I'd have a 661, 362, and 201. If I had to skip one, it would be the 362, as my 036 is my least-used saw. I use the 064 the most, more than double the hours of the other two combined.

On the flip side, if I could own only one saw, it would be 75cc. Yes, I know I criticized it two paragraphs back, because I would not make this the "big saw" in a multi-saw lineup, but it would be the best one-saw compromise for me.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: StihlKicking
Ditto Ashful. Exactly the way I would have said it myself. For two a saw plan it would be my 026 and my 064 but for a single saw my ms 360 would be an easy choice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ashful
My main concern is 50cc with a 20" bar is maxed out and the 60cc saws will run up to a 27" bar with the expense of added weight....ill never run a 27inch but the 60cc saws come with a 24in bar which would make dropping the bigger stuff easier.
This will be my primary/only saw for felling, trimming, and firewood.

What do you say? 50cc lighter and more nimble vs 60cc more power and bsr length?

I've got 30 mature trees to drop and cut this year...some of them are 30in+.

For what you describe. I would go 60cc with a 16" and 24" bar combo. I think that a 600/620 or 362 is about perfect with a 16" bar and, depending on how it handles in your wood, possibly an 8t rim, while retaining the option to jump to 24"/7t on occasion.
 
Damn, I hate wasting the few minutes it takes to change my chain and clean my bar, let alone swapping sprockets in the field. I'm not saying a 362 can't run a 24" bar, but if you're at the point of swapping sprockets with your bars to make it work, I'd just buy a bigger saw.

Also, the beauty of the 362, for anyone who grew up running much older and slower saws, is it's chain speed. You're taking away the only thing I like about that saw! :p
 
I was dead set on a makita/dolmar 6100, but there isn't a dealer within 40 miles...same with jonsered (not including menards).

The stihl dealers all seem a little more knowledgable...but they still had that deer in the headlights look when I asked about pro saws.

Im a mechanic/welder by trade so I can fix most things....i just can't afford to have the down time when I need my tools.

I tend to buy better quality than I need...a rancher saw would probably do just fine but I'm getting a pro saw.
So I look for quality and value...not bargain.

So I'm set on a 60cc...now to throw a wrench in the mix...cs620p...the stihl is outside of my budget when I'm honest with myself.

Please and thank you
Appreciate the replies
God bless
Shred

One of the prime reasons I'd suggest a Dol-kita 6100: it just runs. No need for dealer-dependency. And, prices simply blow stihl away. Not exactly sucking wind, performance-wise either- a 6100 can make a stihl 362 look "delicate" by comparison. "Pro" quality & homeowner prices.

Another challenge with 441 stihl is their stupid-complexity. Was handed one a bit back to r&r p&c on because it had "indigestion" sucking metallic debris back from the muffler. Unbelievable Rube Goldberg maze of poo to untangle to get at the engine. Never again, life's too short.
 
Here's my thoughts for the OP. For me, I'm a bit of saw nerd and have owned most every major brand over the years. I was replacing the AV rubber mounts and servicing my MS361 just this morning, and recently added an MS650 to my fleet, just to see how it compares to my MS660.

I firmly believe after working and operating so many of them over the years, that you just can't beat a PRO Stihl saw, additional costs removed from the equation. I have 8 "pro" class saws currently, and not one of the Dolmar, Jonsered, or Husqvarna's has the build quality of the Stihls. Don't get me wrong, I like Dolmars, Husky, Jonsered, and Echo saws, but over time, little stuff breaks on them more often than it does on the Stihl's. And having torn almost all of them fully apart over the years, the Stihl's are just better designed, better made, and use higher quality components. I greatly enjoy bucking with a Husqvarna 372XP, but it still lacks in a few areas for build quality, IMO.

I'm modifying a Dolmar 6400 with a big bore kit right now, as I like those saws as well. They fit me great, and are tough to beat for the money. But from the factory, they're heavier and not as powerful in the wood as a 361/362. Even though on paper they look comparable, in use, they're not even close. I've had the chance to run a 361, 362, and the 6400 back to back and side by side in big oak, and the 361 narrowly beat out the 362, but they both kicked the Dolmar's butt. And I currently own 3 of the Dolmars 6400's, so I like them, but when working on them, they aren't as well built as the PRO Stihl saws.

If you use it enough over they years, you'd probably have better luck with the Stihl, IMO. Is it worth the extra $$? That's up to you. All I can say is having worked on, owned, and modified several saws over the years, Stihl's PRO saws always stand above the other brands for quality in a lot of little ways.

A lot of tree professionals argue between Husqvarna and Stihl nowdays, and it's whatever you like, dealer support and preference, etc.. They'll all cut wood, that's for sure.

Because of the high costs, I ran several other brands of saws for many years before stepping up and buying my first Stihl PRO saw, but can honestly say that I think there's just a big difference in a lot of little things on the Stihl's that make them worth the money, that don't show up on paper or when holding them up and comparing them in a store.
 
I would suggest to take a look at the efco-oleomac line of chainsaws. Good price and good quality, at least in the below-70cc line. A good 60cc with a 20 inch bar can handle almost everything (for home use I mean).
 
If I could only own 1 saw, it would be a Stihl MS361/362. Great power to weight, and they have been so reliable and fun to use over the years. And both of the 361's that I've owned cut wood as if they had 20 more cc's hiding under the hood than they actually do. For some reason, those saws are freaks. My only hiccup has been when the new 362C-M came out, we personally experienced some growing pains with the new electronic carb systems, but that has now been worked out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ashful
60cc is the "one saw" compromise, and one could argue it's a decent compromise. I have a 85cc, 63cc, and a 35cc top handle saw, and find this is the ideal saw plan... if you don't mind having that sort of money tied up in saws. I cut with a guy who has a 75cc saw in is three-saw lineup, and find it's too small for big wood while too heavy for small wood, but we all have different preferences and stamina.

Two of my saws were pre-owned low-hours saws, because I try to be frugal, when it's not going to cost me time or frustration. If I were buying new today, I'd have a 661, 362, and 201. If I had to skip one, it would be the 362, as my 036 is my least-used saw. I use the 064 the most, more than double the hours of the other two combined.

On the flip side, if I could own only one saw, it would be 75cc. Yes, I know I criticized it two paragraphs back, because I would not make this the "big saw" in a multi-saw lineup, but it would be the best one-saw compromise for me.

"If I were buying new today, I'd have a 661, 362, and 201."

I just read this post tonight, as I had skipped over them earlier, but couldn't agree more. The 661 is a pretty heavy saw, when you're using it for hours on end, and my 660 seems to be getting heavier the older I get. That 461 is a great saw, but is also a bit heavy for me if I'm bucking with it for hours on end, that's why I still think the 362 is the saw to use for firewood. Great balance and power, it's right in the sweet spot for me.

Thankfully, having a few pro saws is the way to go, if you can justify it. When I've got a lot of trees to drop, and not a lot of time available, it's nice to have big saws with big bars ready to go, and small saws standing by for the limbing duties, then a medium size saw for the bucking it all up if you're going to make firewood from it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ashful
It always helps to have a couple saws for cutting in different situations and different sized wood. But I have to agree with Dodgy stihl pro saws are second to none. Between me and my father we have a 039 a 361 and a 660 we use to cut wood with. The first to are great saws no complaints the 039 has been used since the day it was purchased brand new. My father is 60 years old but you would not know that looking at him he still is an animal when it comes to getting work done. When we are cutting nine out of ten times he grabs the 660 even for cutting smaller stuff. The saw is a little bigger and heavier than the other two, but the power is night and day. Now everyone has there personal preferences for size and weight that they want to handle when cutting all day, but in my opinion the bigger 660 is the way to go. You can always get a smaller bar and chain if needed. This is just my personal thoughts but more times than not the bigger saw comes in handy, I have buddies that are always in need of a bigger saw to get through big wood. These smaller saws will do it, just that they will work harder and longer to get the job done. It's never a bad idea to have one bigger saw, worse comes to worse it sits till it's needed.
 
I would definitely agree with the previous posts on saw/bar combos. For 30 years I ran my Pioneer P50 (85cc) with a 20" bar for everything from limbing to blocking. Only once or twice in all those years did I switch to a 30" bar for larger stuff. If it were me and I were limited to one saw I would buy a 60-70cc with a max recommended bar for the occasional bigger log, and an 18" bar for everything else. I am a firm believer in not being underpowered and the difference in the weight of the saw (less bar) between a 50cc and a 70cc is negligible.
 
If I could only own 1 saw, it would be a Stihl MS361/362. Great power to weight, and they have been so reliable and fun to use over the years. And both of the 361's that I've owned cut wood as if they had 20 more cc's hiding under the hood than they actually do. For some reason, those saws are freaks. My only hiccup has been when the new 362C-M came out, we personally experienced some growing pains with the new electronic carb systems, but that has now been worked out.
Seems to me you've not tried a Dolmar 6100. IME, makes stihl 36x seem like brake's dragging. Pro quality, ease of service (way better than typical stihl), excellent performance, great value. Many Dolmar models make competitive stihls look like overpriced also-rans. Pretty plastic, though.
And ... for the price of those stihls, I'd look at a 562XP, for a bunch of reasons. Just not a stihl fanboy, sorry. Too many better options IMO.
 
I run Dolmars for most everything. I do have 1 Stilh, 084 , 120cc of pure nasty with a 48" bar ( because Dolmar doesn't have one that big on this side of the pond.) in the past 20 years I have had one failure on my Dolmars , a 7900 Dolmar- base gasket- Must have been a problem in that area as Dolmar change the gasket material- no issues since. 2-7900, 6400,6401, 116si,112 oh and there is a little 35cc echo in the mix as well.
 
Link Removed Link Removed Link Removed Link Removed
Seems to me you've not tried a Dolmar 6100. IME, makes stihl 36x seem like brake's dragging. Pro quality, ease of service (way better than typical stihl), excellent performance, great value. Many Dolmar models make competitive stihls look like overpriced also-rans. Pretty plastic, though.
And ... for the price of those stihls, I'd look at a 562XP, for a bunch of reasons. Just not a stihl fanboy, sorry. Too many better options IMO.

I have 3 of the Dolmar 6400's, and I like them very much. I have a big bore kit (7900) for one, and the other two just have muffler mod's good tuning. They're fine saws. My 361 will give them the business, except for the 7900 saw which runs stronger of course.

I'll tell you this, I've just torn those saws down and the Stihl is a better built, higher quality saw in multiple ways. But, they do cost more.
 

Attachments

  • [Hearth.com] Need chainsaw advice...bigger or lighter?
    20170529_142242.webp
    391.8 KB · Views: 323
  • [Hearth.com] Need chainsaw advice...bigger or lighter?
    20170529_142148.webp
    364 KB · Views: 327
Seems to me you've not tried a Dolmar 6100. IME, makes stihl 36x seem like brake's dragging. Pro quality, ease of service (way better than typical stihl), excellent performance, great value. Many Dolmar models make competitive stihls look like overpriced also-rans. Pretty plastic, though.
And ... for the price of those stihls, I'd look at a 562XP, for a bunch of reasons. Just not a stihl fanboy, sorry. Too many better options IMO.
I second the 562xp. Just bought one to replace my 262xp, and it is an amazing saw. Easy starter, tonnes of power, smooth running and quieter than my 262xp. I'm very happy with it, and I bought their fuel too so it has a 4 year warranty. Very happy with it, can't wait for next weekend when I can do some more cutting with it.

Sent from my LG-H812 using Tapatalk
 
Dodgy, some collection of saws. Obviously your opinion comes from years of experience. I'm with you, Pro series Stihl's are as well built as any saw out there. They may cost a bit more, but you can see the difference.

So to address the original question. If this is a one time home owner project. Why not rent the big saw. Buy the best saw you can afford. Buy a saw that you can use everyday. I'm a one saw guy. For me it's a 260 Pro with 18 inch bar. Light enough and powerful.