Todd and I have spoken pretty regularly over the years and he contributed to the deicision. I offered to sent him a stove or parts since my dealer's prices were pretty good. These cat stoves are definitely more complicated to operate. The wife couldn't believe all the rules but I'm sure we'll get a rhythm down.
Big question for cat stoves. Can I use my little chunks of fire starter? I bought the box at walmart and chopped them up into golf ball sized chunks that work great for firestarting. They surely have some wax and also sawdust looking stuff. The manual specifies no coal or liquid starters but says nothing about wax.
I found a bunch of black and white paper for the first startup. BK did NOT include a supercedar in my stove.
Also, the cat was ceramic, not SS and my stove was made in July of 2011. Nice big holes that look hard to clog.
I think you'll find it really simple to use. The only real rules are to feed it dry wood, and make sure it's hot enough to close the bypass. And don't just open the door when the cat is hot, thermal shock is bad. My wife was a pro by the first time I was gone for work. Super easy once you determine what t-stat settings work for you with given weather conditions.
Your firestarter will be all burned up before you send any smoke through the cat. You won't use very many. I lit the first one in early December, then shut it down at the end of January to check the chimney. I let it go cold a couple of times during the spring. I think I lit four of them.