I got the flat black...they didn't have any colors set up to temp us. I love the black cast iron look. I'll send picks when it's installed. I brought it in the house yesterday. My wife wants to call rockys and see how much they will charge to set it up...I'm of the opinion that I can do it and that had been the plan. But we will see.
I say I would prefer the blue black . . . and still would . . . but as I also said, the cast iron black look is fine as well . . . and it does a good job.
Depending on the install . . . it could be relatively simple or a challenge. Another possible option to hiring the shop do it is to check around with CSIA-certified chimney sweeps.