Hi, folks -
I was inspired by this thread to replace the baffle in my Hearthstone Homestead (2007 vintage) with
concrete firebricks from Lowes. I'd gotten really tired of the fragility and expense of the stock baffle, plus the replacements I'd purchased always left gaps at the top of the firebox, reducing the stove's efficiency.
It took four bricks to make a new baffle, and I had to make an angled cut on each to allow the baffle support (the small steel plate on top of the secondary air manifold) to lie down on the bricks without unduly occluding the passage of exhaust above the baffle. I took the small pieces of brick I cut off and put them behind the bricks to prevent them from sliding toward the rear of the stove (i.e., keeping them exactly where needed to cover the top of the firebox).
I'm about 10 days into the experiment, and the stove is running better than it ever has before. Very clean burns and good secondary combustion even soon after lighting a fire.
I don't yet know how durable the bricks will be through many heating and cooling cycles, but they show no sign of wear right now. I'll try to remember to come back here and update this post when I have more data.
Thanks to all of the contributors here for good thoughts and advice!