pgmr said:
The other thing that heat in the attic can do is melt snow cover from below, causing melt water to refreeze at the eaves, causing ice dams. We were having that recently and I wrapped the exposed part of the chimney with R-25 unfaced fiberglass. It seems to have helped quite a bit.
I have an interior masonry chimney that goes through the attic. It gets warm enough up there to create the same problem you mention. In fact, I just started a thread in the Hearth Room that contains a YouTube video of my chimney. You can clearly see the melting problem in the video.
Had the ladder out the other day, chopping holes in the dam so water could drain out. Otherwise, if we get a warm, rainy spell, the water backs up under the shingles and wicks right onto the living room ceiling. Cost me two days work last time I neglected it. The sheetrock got so soft I had to cut out parts and replace them, then tape, spackle, prime, paint... Finally got smart and made a snow rake. Of course, I haven't used it today and we had almost a foot of snow here yesterday. Glad you reminded me.