Stove Recommendations

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
  • Hope everyone has a wonderful and warm Thanksgiving!
  • Super Cedar firestarters 30% discount Use code Hearth2024 Click here

Big Schoolhouse

New Member
Dec 10, 2024
5
Ohio
New to the site but love all the information. You guys are amazing. I am looking for some recommendations and advice on a wood stove. I have an open floor plan, two story 1870 brick schoolhouse. There is no insulation in the walls, just 3 brick wide walls. Ceilings are 12 ft downstairs and up. The downstairs is open floor plan. Upstairs the bathroom and bedrooms are situated around the staircase/ open hallway. We currently have a heat pump/ electric furnace which runs constantly when cold. I have pretty reliable and free access to wood so I would like to add a wood burning stove as a primary heat source. The house has a chimney that runs up the middle of the house which would allow plenty of heat to make its way up the center staircase to the upper floor. The house is 2400 sq ft split evenly between floors.

The chimney is original but in good shape except for not having a liner. I recently cleaned the chimney and have ordered a 6" Rock Flex liner which I plan to install this weekend. The chimney is tall and from thimble to exit will be about 30'. I will need an additional 6' or so of stove pipe to get from the appliance to the thimble connection. I would like to heat the entire first floor and have enough warm air escape upstairs through the stairwell that will keep the chill down upstairs. I could also run our furnace fan to help circulate air if necessary.

I want a stove that will be a reliable source of heat and burn through most of the night or work day on a load of wood. I have been looking at some of the Drolet models such as the Decos. I have an opportunity to purchase a new but discontinued 2015 Napoleon Banff 1400 C (Majolica Brown Enamel) for $1000 or a new but discontinued Napoleon 1400C for $500. Both of those stoves are rated up to 2000 sq ft, 9 hours of burn time and 27" deep. The Drolet Deco Alto has a similar capacity and depth. The Drolet Deco II is slightly smaller in all accounts. I have the space but would prefer a stove that is not so deep which gives preference to the Deco II but I am afraid it does not have enough capacity.

I have a few questions:
1. Will my stove choices accomplish my heating needs?
2. Would the long chimney length have an impact on the Drolets? I read they would need to be dampened down.
3. Is one of these stove brands better than the other in terms of ease of use, lifespan, parts supply, etc.?
4. Can these stoves sit as close to the brick chimney as possible without issue? I imagine I will lose a little space because of the elbow connection to the chimney but would like the stove to be as close to the chimney as possible.
5. Should I use double or single wall pipe from the stove to the chimney? Clearances to ceilings and walls are will not an issue, only the brick masonry chimney itself.
6. Anything else I should know or be aware of in this wood stove adventure?

Thank you all for your knowledge and expertise.
 
New to the site but love all the information. You guys are amazing. I am looking for some recommendations and advice on a wood stove. I have an open floor plan, two story 1870 brick schoolhouse. There is no insulation in the walls, just 3 brick wide walls. Ceilings are 12 ft downstairs and up. The downstairs is open floor plan. Upstairs the bathroom and bedrooms are situated around the staircase/ open hallway. We currently have a heat pump/ electric furnace which runs constantly when cold. I have pretty reliable and free access to wood so I would like to add a wood burning stove as a primary heat source. The house has a chimney that runs up the middle of the house which would allow plenty of heat to make its way up the center staircase to the upper floor. The house is 2400 sq ft split evenly between floors.

The chimney is original but in good shape except for not having a liner. I recently cleaned the chimney and have ordered a 6" Rock Flex liner which I plan to install this weekend. The chimney is tall and from thimble to exit will be about 30'. I will need an additional 6' or so of stove pipe to get from the appliance to the thimble connection. I would like to heat the entire first floor and have enough warm air escape upstairs through the stairwell that will keep the chill down upstairs. I could also run our furnace fan to help circulate air if necessary.

I want a stove that will be a reliable source of heat and burn through most of the night or work day on a load of wood. I have been looking at some of the Drolet models such as the Decos. I have an opportunity to purchase a new but discontinued 2015 Napoleon Banff 1400 C (Majolica Brown Enamel) for $1000 or a new but discontinued Napoleon 1400C for $500. Both of those stoves are rated up to 2000 sq ft, 9 hours of burn time and 27" deep. The Drolet Deco Alto has a similar capacity and depth. The Drolet Deco II is slightly smaller in all accounts. I have the space but would prefer a stove that is not so deep which gives preference to the Deco II but I am afraid it does not have enough capacity.

I have a few questions:
1. Will my stove choices accomplish my heating needs?
2. Would the long chimney length have an impact on the Drolets? I read they would need to be dampened down.
3. Is one of these stove brands better than the other in terms of ease of use, lifespan, parts supply, etc.?
4. Can these stoves sit as close to the brick chimney as possible without issue? I imagine I will lose a little space because of the elbow connection to the chimney but would like the stove to be as close to the chimney as possible.
5. Should I use double or single wall pipe from the stove to the chimney? Clearances to ceilings and walls are will not an issue, only the brick masonry chimney itself.
6. Anything else I should know or be aware of in this wood stove adventure?

Thank you all for your knowledge and expertise.
2400 sq ft with 12' ceilings and no insulation? You need a furnace to keep up with that space
 
2400 sq ft with 12' ceilings and no insulation? You need a furnace to keep up with that space
I think adding a wood furnace would be require more than what I am wanting to spend. The center chimney and wood stove option seemed like the best way to lower my heating bill. I just can't stand to hear my heat pump and auxiliary heat run non stop all winter again. I like the upstairs to be considerably cooler for sleeping comfort. My biggest concern is the 1200 sq ft downstairs. Any heat that rises upstairs would be a bonus.
 
I think adding a wood furnace would be require more than what I am wanting to spend. The center chimney and wood stove option seemed like the best way to lower my heating bill. I just can't stand to hear my heat pump and auxiliary heat run non stop all winter again. I like the upstairs to be considerably cooler for sleeping comfort. My biggest concern is the 1200 sq ft downstairs. Any heat that rises upstairs would be a bonus.
Ok but even 1200 sqft 12' tall and no insulation is a big job. Those soft ratings are 8' ceilings with average insulation
 
The ht-3000 is over 31" deep. I don't intend for the stove to supply all the heat. My expectation is that it will burn overnight and reduce the cost from my currently all electric heat pump that runs constantly when temperatures drop. If the center chimney and smaller stove does not work out the way I expect I can install an insert in the fireplace located on one of the exterior walls. The reason I didn't do that initially is because lining that chimney is goin to involve much more work. I also thought the center chimney would heat the entire area better since it was centrally located.
 
Having recently left Ohio I'll say my stove was able to heat the place for when that was my only heat. It happened 6 or 8 times while I was there. Outside temp -20 I could keep the place from Freezing.

You have a large open open Floorplan. A large stove wouldn't get lost in the space and wouldn't stand out as huge.
 
The ht-3000 is over 31" deep. I don't intend for the stove to supply all the heat. My expectation is that it will burn overnight and reduce the cost from my currently all electric heat pump that runs constantly when temperatures drop. If the center chimney and smaller stove does not work out the way I expect I can install an insert in the fireplace located on one of the exterior walls. The reason I didn't do that initially is because lining that chimney is goin to involve much more work. I also thought the center chimney would heat the entire area better since it was centrally located.
Go large. Some of the heat will go upstairs. A 3 cu ft Drolet is what I would put in. In addition to the HT-3000 there is the Astral/Myriad/Legend family. Also, I'd put in a ceiling fan in the stove room. Run it in reverse (winter mode) when the stove is running.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pinesmoke
Go large. Some of the heat will go upstairs. A 3 cu ft Drolet is what I would put in. In addition to the HT-3000 there is the Astral/Myriad/Legend family. Also, I'd put in a ceiling fan in the stove room. Run it in reverse (winter mode) when the stove is running.
Good point on the fans. I take that for granted. We have them in every room except the bathrooms. We have 10 1/2 foot ceilings and they move the heat down and stir the place around.
 
There is a ceiling fan directly at the top of the stairs. Should I run it opposite to keep heat down in the main living area? Normally I would try to pull heat upstairs but I think running the furnace blower would pull enough warm air into the return vent and into the duct work upstairs. Anyone have answers on the stove pipe clearance to the brick chimney and whether to run double or single wall black pipe? Also, has anyone bought stoves from home stores? I saw this stove listed and it says its rated for 3500 sq ft. Made in China though. I find the ratings hard to believe for the size.

Hansabenne Stove
 
As far as I can tell that stove has little or no secondary combustion and is not EPA approved for sale in America. It looks like they are selling it as a "fireplace" to get around regs. FYI, the installation instructions are a bad joke, lots of errors.

Get a big Drolet. Made in Canada and SBI stands behind their products. Or get a big Englander which is now a branch of SBI and made in America. The 300L appears to be based on the Drolet Escape 1800.
 
Last edited: