I have two of the HF wood carts, and think they are well worth the money. However I found it interesting that even though they both have the same part number and description, they are significantly different... My older one matches the description, but the spokes on the wheels were loose when I got them, and they got progressively worse until one of them collapsed on me.
This is when I got the second cart, which I left in the box for several months because I was able to get the local pedal-bike shop to fix the wheels from the first cart (cost me about $10 a wheel) Now they wobble a lot, but the cart is usable...
I then had a friend ask me to help him move some wood while my old cart was full, so I decided to put the new one together - I found it had MUCH stronger wheels - the hubs were about an inch wider, and the spokes were significantly heavier duty - however the tires and tubes were still crap - my friend blew one tire and tube off just trying to air it up at assembly....
Subsequently, I discovered that while the old cart fit through a standard door no problem (albeit without a lot of room to spare) the new cart would NOT - I got out the tape measure and started comparing the two carts and found that the people at HF had compensated for the new stronger wheels by making the axle longer, with the result that the cart was wider than the dimension listed in the catalog...
After discovering this, it was only a couple of hours work to trim about an inch off the ends of the axle, the same off the pipe wheel spacers, and drill new holes for the cotter pins. The result was a cart that was the same width as the old one, and which would now go through doors w/o a problem... It IS narrower between the wheels, so I would say that the maximum split length it could fit would be about 21", but since I cut to 18" and reject anything over 20", that isn't a big deal. (because of the distance between the rails, it won't carry anything shorter than 12-14" either) Since the much stronger wheels on this cart actually run true, I find it is no harder to center the logs that need to fit between the wheels on this cart than I do on the wobbly wheeled older version... Once you get the logs stacked higher than the wheels the centering is not critical anyway.
As another part of fixing the cart, I had to replace the tire that my friend blew up - went to Wal-mart and got a couple of tires, and even though they were much more expensive, decided to try a pair of the new "No-more-flats" solid foam rubber "tubes" they were selling - about $14 each instead of $6 for the regular tubes.... These are a hard foam rubber donut that go into the tire instead of a tube, with the claim that they won't ever go flat, and never need air (and have no fill valve)... They are a BEAST to install - the instructions say to use lots of soap, and they aren't kidding, I found that you basically need to completely coat the tube and the inside of the tire with soap to get them installed. However I've been very happy with the result - the tires are nice and hard, roll well, and it's nice not to have to worry about ever blowing them up again...
Another difference I did notice, is that the new cart holds less wood than the old one - however, putting the two carts side by side, I don't think this is because of a design change on HF's part, but more that the old cart has gotten a bit "splayed out" where the tubes have bent out just enough that they are more angled, giving a bit more capacity than the new cart - just says I need to overload the new cart more... :coolsmirk:
I use the cart during heating season to bring wood into the house - which involves dragging it up eight or nine steps depending on how you want to count... Not "fun" but the big wheels make it about as easy as such a task can be - it is no worse than using an appliance dolly.
In the summer I use it for moving wood from the backup stacks to the wood shed, and any other wood moving tasks, including dragging stuff that I've cut out of the woods - does a good job of that. The only limitation I've found is that it doesn't like large (over about 12") rounds as they seem to put to much "point load" strain on the cart instead of a distributed load. Not a big deal, I just use a different cart for the bigger rounds.
IMHO the HF cart may take some extra work to put into service, but it's worth it.
Gooserider