kpikul said:
Thanks. I have my own guy to install it and I do not need very large stove as I am only heat roughly 1000 sqft. I am having trouble finding any type of reviews on either of these stoves.
Does anyone out there have an unbais opinion about these 2 brands?
All of our opinions are biased, and so are the reviews! (ratings section here), but maybe you should look through the ratings a bit!
They are a different size, and with stoves - size does matter.
Napoleon used to be a "third tier" brand, but they have invested a lot of time and money in the last couple years into their operations, and the stuff looks nice now. Regency has been going at it since 1979, and probably growing slowly all along (and quite large now)...
About the only comment I can make is both the size diff and also that the two brands tend to go to "market" in different ways. Regency typically has specialty dealers who have been selling the brand for a long time (close relationship with manufacturer)...Napoleon markets through just about anybody - chimney sweeps, etc. - that is neither good nor bad, but why I mentioned that you should feel somewhat comfortable with your dealer......not as important (but still important) if you are having someone else install it.
We often have the "bang for the buck" discussion here, and the truth is that none of these very fancy detailed stoves are going to offer you as much per dollar spent as a plain jane stove, but as Elk says it is a piece of furniture. So you look at your checkbook, and as my brother used to say "ask yourself if you will live any differently because you are out that $2300" (will it make TOO big of a dent in the budget), and if not....then you and your mate (or whoever else is involved) should make the decision.
Going back to square #1, are you comfortable with a very small to medium-small firebox and a 6-8 hour burn? Many people are, but if your wood pile is large and you really want 24/7 burning, you'd want to look at stoves well over 2 cubic foot firebox. Many companies sell these - including Vermont Castings, Jotul, Travis Industries and maybe even Hampton/Regency. Look at the cubic size of box and burn time in relation.
My general guide is:
1.5 = small firebox
2.2 = medium firebox
3.0 = large firebox
very general, of course! Note that a big firebox is no a good thing if you have a smaller area to heat and a relatively small wood supply! A stove should match the job it is expected to do.