6/5/96 - - - Back to List archives - Back to Club House
1. More on metal roofs
2. Reprints of Hearth and Home articles?
3.World Wide Hearth Industry - Ventless Opinions from down under.
6/6/96
1. Hearth and HPA
2. On the road and reply to above
6/13/96
1. HPA and Hearth, Rumor
2. hpa vs hearth
3. Warranty
4. Response to Warranty
6/14/96
1. FREE Email
2. VC-CFM merger complete - things heating up !
6/16/96
1. A reps spin on Warranty Matters
2. HPA and Hearth - Why can't we all get along ?
6/18/96
1. Ventless Legal in California ?
6/19/96
1. HPA Education Director on FIREWRIGHT
2. Note on above
6/21/96
1. Concern about Unvented in Ca.
2. Advice for the Retailer
3.New Bulletin Board for Communications
4. Firewright Program - Description
6/22/96
1. Comment on EDI, Communication, Bulletin Boards, etc.
2. Will not Sell Ventless
6/22/96#2
1. Good Things about Ventless
2. Flame wars ?
6/24/96
1. Efforts on gas safety
6/26/96
1. QuadraFire cleaner than ever ..
2. Direct Sales on the NET
3. Comment on direct sales
6/29/96
1.Suggested Purchase order Boilerplate ?
2. VC/CFM Article/Hearth and Home
6/30/96
1. Answers about Proposed Purchase Order text
2. Comment on Bulletin Boards


Hearth Digest 6/5/96
In this issue:

1. More on metal roofs
2. Reprints of Hearth and Home articles?
3.World Wide Hearth Industry - Ventless Opinions from down under.

1. More on metal roof To: [email protected] Subject: Metal roofs

Tim Nissen wrote the other day about flashings for use on standing seam metal roofing. I certainly hope that neoprene or some other material gets approved for use. We have been doing a fair amount of work on metal roofs for about 15 years and the one thing I can tell you is that the lead flashing will get eaten away by electrolysis, just like on boats. The time frame seems (no pun intended) to vary from 3-10 years before significant softening occurs and a hole develops. We have not found a long term answer. Anyone else? Skip Stahmer Sierra Timberline Grass Valley, CA
____________________

2. Reprints of Herth and Home articles?
From: Jeff Palmer
Subject: vent-free

I would like to see articles by Paul Stegmier and Tom Greiner(both are in this months Hearth And Home) on vent-free products and indoor air quality made available to the retail consumer. Please e-mail response. Thanks

Craig Issod ([email protected]) responds to above :
I'm not sure if these articles are "owned" by Hearth and Home magazine,GRI, HPA or by the Authors. Since Richard Wright and Paul Stegmier are on the list, I invite them to answer (on the list or privately to you) ______________________________________________________

3.World Wide Hearth Industry - Ventless Opinions from down under.

Craig Issod ([email protected]) says:

Received the following email from Australia today. I'm constantly amazed by the WORLDWIDE audience on HearthNet, and the communication that is taking place between interest parties...We do live in interesting times....

Dear Sir/Madam Thank you for your informative articles , which I have printed out and distributed to various sales people in the industry here in Sydney Australia However I would like to add to your article on ventless gas fires two important aspects 1. The production of moisture , which causes mildew with its associated problems 2.The safety w.r.t.burning of children and old people

Regards Karel de Keijzer de Keijzer Designer Fires (all glass open fires)

Hearth Digest 6/6/96
IN this issue:

1. Hearth and HPA
2. On the road and reply to above

1. Hearth and HPA

To: [email protected]
From: [email protected] (jonathan a. harman)
Subject: HPA and Hearth, Rumor

The first thing that comes to mind is: Why re-invent the wheel?

Why would HPA want to add another burden to its budget? Does someone need a job? If there are two certifications available, will some states want HPA only and others want Hearth only? Will this eventually get to the county level? This could be a potential pain in the butt and wallet for the specialty retailer.

If I remember correctly, our industry was divided into to trade organizations (Wood Energy Institute and ....????). They grew up and became the Hearth Products Association. Why would the HPA suggest a step backwards?

I hope I read this wrong or I am dreaming. Last thing our industry needs is to be torn apart form inside itself. The tree-huggers are bad enough.

RUMOR:

I heard that room vented heaters are going to be leagal in California by May next year. Is there any truth to this?

Once again, Craig thanks for your efforts.

Jon _______________________________


2. Craig Issod ([email protected]) says:

I'm going to Disney World till next thursday, so they will probably not be any digests during that time...I will be checking my email with my portable, and if there is any important or timely posts, I'll email them to the list from from Florida....

As far as Hearth and HPA, I regret that I am not well enough informed to make an honest appraisal of the current situation.

My own experience this year , when HPA "forced" Hearth to cancel the retailers' discussion of Ventless at Charlotte, did leave me with the impression that I wanted certain informational and educational freedom within our industry. However, this freedom can also be exercised thru forums like this, though trade magazines (when they are feeling bold), and thru the normal channels of dealer and manufacturer communication.

As it is, the general educational part of the HEARTH program has already been passed to HPA...I think it's just the certification and testing part that's on the table now.

I would also feel better if there were representatives from the retail level helping to spec, create and implement any eduational programs.Call me skeptical, but I don't want to be told what to learn by a group consisiting of mostly manufacturers. Based on my experience, there is more product and real world knowledge existing within the retailer group in our org, than is in the manufacturing side.

Goodnight to all, and thanks for listening and posting....
Craig Issod [email protected]

Hearth Digest 6/13/96

Greetings to the list..have just returned from Disney World....Had a good time, but more importantly learned a few things...Most important of all is that imagination and creativity are the driving forces of our journey into the future...

In this issue:

1. HPA and Hearth, Rumor
2. hpa vs hearth
3. Warranty
4. Response to Warranty

1. HPA and Hearth, Rumor

From: [email protected] (jonathan a. harman)
Subject: HPA and Hearth, Rumor

Craig,

The first thing that comes to mind is: Why re-invent the wheel?

Why would HPA want to add another burden to its budget? Does someone need a job? If there are two certifications available, will some states want HPA only and others want Hearth only? Will this eventually get to the county level? This could be a potential pain in the butt and wallet for the specialty retailer.

If I remember correctly, our industry was divided into to trade organizations (Wood Energy Institute and ....????). They grew up and became the Hearth Products Association. Why would the HPA suggest a step backwards?

I hope I read this wrong or I am dreaming. Last thing our industry needs is to be torn apart form inside itself. The tree-huggers are bad enough.

RUMOR:

I heard that room vented heaters are going to be leagal in California by May next year. Is there any truth to this?

Once again, Craig thanks for your efforts.

Jon ________________________________

2. hpa vs hearth

Date: Sun, 9 Jun 96 18:00:57 UT From: "PAT MARTIN" <[email protected]> To: [email protected] Subject: hpa vs hearth

I talked to Carter yesterday and he told me that it basically came down to the way Hearth wanted to distribute resources within the HPA. The HPA has already hired an education director so it looks like the HPA is going to have its own certification proccess.

I am by no means an expert but I would expect that Hearth is going to have serious problems unless they at least mend the fences a little. As someone who would be looking for a "certification" I can tell you that I would not get that certification unless it is reconized by the HPA.

Pat Martin

3.Warranty

Date: Mon, 10 Jun 96 18:00:16 UT From: "John Wallace" <[email protected]> Subject: Warranty

I need some feedback. Please! With the coming of gas products along with pellet products. There is more & more money going out for warranty work and less coming back to the dealers. We try to pre-burn almost all gas & pellet products before they are installed. There is still more warranty work than I think there should be.

When most manufacturers state on the back of their "Warranty" form that they cover labor and parts for 12 months. I think that is miss leading, in fact most (not all ) only cover a portion of the labor, and expect the dealer to pick up the remainder.

I think that the manufacturers should put in writing what they will pay on each service call. ie $35.00 for !!!!!! , $20.00 for !!!!!!, or state that they only cover a portion of the labor. Then it would be up to the dealer to fill in the blanks.

We try to cover this with each sale, we also offer an extended labor warranty pkg. Some take it and some don't.

Please I need feed-back and any help I can get. Am I the only dealer with this concern. ________________________ 4. Response to Warranty From Craig Issod, [email protected]


In the message above, John Wallace States:\

>Am I the only dealer with this >concern. John, I can assure you that you are not the only dealer with this concern. Most of the manufacturers I have dealt with do not cover their written warranties in (my humble opinion) the proper matter. This includes some of the biggest names in the industry, such as Peterson Logs, Temco, Travis and others.

Peterson , for example, claims :We NEVER pay any labor of any type for replacement of defective parts ...quite a warranty from the oldest manufacturer of logs ! If I told this to a customer previous to their purchase, I would never make a sale...so, of course we end up eating all the service calles. Temco also does not pay for any labor, service calls, etc...In the 12 years I have done business with them, I have yet to collect any money for our service. They do replace the parts, and or units that are bad without too much trouble. Luckily for us, the great margins we receive on the product allow us to build-in a service factor. Travis does have a labor schedule, but always seems reluctant to cover the actual REAL cost of such repairs...To their credit --we don't have hardly any problems...so this has never become an issue...but if they ever do have a rash of field problems, I hope they will take a hint from VC.

In my experience, Vermont Castings is King of the Hill when it comes to proper warranty reimbursement. They handle each dealer EXACTLY AS THE DEALERS' CUSTOMER WOULD EXPECT TO BE HANDLED..it's really very simple, being tight with warranty money and credits adds insult to injury to both the dealer and the end user. Any manufacturer that can not see this clearly is stuck in an old way of thinking.

Hearthstone has also been good covering the small problems we have experienced.

Would love to hear thoughts from both the makers and dealers out there - this is an important issue...

Hearth Digest 6/14

In this issue:

1. FREE Email
2. VC-CFM merger complete - things heating up !

1. Jon, from Hearthside in California, has found a new service which offers FREE EMAIL accounts to those who could care less about web access. This is a perfect way to get your friends wired. Here is the info:

"It requires: 386 or higher, windows 3.1 or higher, 4MB ram, 10MB disk space, 3.5" floppy drive, VGA monitor (SVGA recommended), 2400-baud modem (9600 recommended). A copy of thier software can be requested by calling 1(800) 654-JUNO or send it to a friend by e-mailing [email protected]. They also have a web page but I'm not sure of the address. It is probably www.juno.com I would guess."

2. Vermont Castings Merger Complete...Dealers in a tizzy about CFM-VC-Majestic policies (by Craig Issod, [email protected])

Vermont Castings and CFM have completed their merger.

Just when I thought it was safe to go back in the water ! Disturbing news out of Canada..... According to various sources, VC has taken a number of steps which may compromise the interests of their specialty dealers. Please keep in mind that this is currently "rumor". That said, here's the communication:

1. VC has fired all their reps in Canada, giving the line to their CFM reps.

2. All CFM dealers in Canada, including HVAC etc., have been informed that they will have access to the entire VC line, including wood products.

According to these various sources, VC also intends to do the same thing in the US, except it would be Majestic instead of CFM that receives the nod.

According to sources:

"This represents a complete departure from the promise made by VC to their dealer network. Both Dennis Dillion (VC) and Colin Adamson (CFM) have previouly stated that there would be no changes to the existing VC dealer network."

As both a dealer and "reporter" , I have different opinions about the above. For instance, I am currently remodeling my store, and printing new catalogs, building new displays and creating new signs. Without the proper communication, I am unsure how much "space" to give VC. The toughtest part is not just the fact that others can/will sell VC ...but that I will be making a smaller % on many of the items than they do. A shop like ours has a much higher overhead (%) than a "builder wholesaler"., and we cannot survive on 30% margins...in fact, we have averaged close to 40% for the past 5 years !

As far as honesty, morality, ethics, etc....there are many people who throw this stuff out the window when millions of $$ are involved. I would say we all do this to a degree...Altho I hated the expression, my Dad used to say" Craig, we're all whores (sorry ladies), we just have different prices !"..( I still winch when I repeat this).

I'd like to think it isn't so, but ask yourself what you would do for 1 million $$$, for 2 million $$, etc.

The tough thing in life is to balance this against factors like "Do I sleep well at night?" - "Am I truly Happy" - "Can I stand 100% behind what I say?" and of course the famous line from the movie Wall Street "How many Yachts can you water-ski behind?"

Is VC/CFM wrong to take these actions ? It surely is not my position to put a judgement on this...after all, they apparantly did not ever do too well using "the old way" of distribution. I would only ask them to be honest and to share any new opportunities with their long-term customers.

Responses from the dealers involved and VC-CFM-MAJESTIC are welcomed. You can post to the list([email protected]) or to me privately ([email protected])

_______________________________________________

end of digest

Hearth Digest 6/16/96

In this issue:

1. A reps spin on Warranty Matters
2. HPA and Hearth - Why can't we all get along ?

First, a short welcome to all the new members on the list. The list is now at 170 folks and growing....Also, many issues are read by multiple folks so the word gets around pretty good.

Some reminders ...The free "members only" area of HearthNet at http://hearth.com/news/club.html contains the charter and archives for this list, as well as lots of interesting articles, classified section, etc. This is a password restricted area - use username:hearth passwprd:fire

to access these files.

Also, a description of some of our commercial services can be found at http://hearth.com/eight.html


1. From: [email protected] Date: Fri, 14 Jun 1996 08:56:33 -0400 To: [email protected] Subject: My spin on the warranty debate

As a rep. I guess I am destined to look at issues from both sides to see what is best for the retailer and still keep the manufacturer happy.

As usual there are parites on both sides who abuse any situation. Most of the time the result of these abuses are taken out on NEXT warranty situation that dealer or manufacturer faces. A dealer of mine just submitted a bill for $96.00 per hour because the manufactuer stated labor would be covered. The issue was the placement of a comma in the warranty statement and they listed the labor rate on a seperate sheet from the warranty statement!

Who covers the service call when you discover the problem is not a factory defect? Most of the time sooting is a simple balance of gas and air. Manufacturer's preset their stoves for typical installations but each situation can be different. A thermostat wire gets a "nick" in it which causes the unit to shut down once in a while. After several years of selling gas appliances, I would guess that the majority of service calls I have been involved with for my dealers HAVE NOT been factory defects. However in each situation, the manufaturer was expected to pay the way.

My personal feeling is that the solution is contained in one word...EDUCATION. The dealers and installers who truly know and understand gas products are the guys who seem to submit the most reasonable claims. Gas appliances require a lot of knowledge to install and trouble shoot correctly. When we started with them most of the manufactueres didn't have the expertise. Now they are getting up to speed but dealers and reps. now need to learn what we are doing. Once the eduaction process is underway, the disputes seem to get smaller and smaller. Both sides seem to understand the situation better and warranty claims are much easier to swallow.

The bottom line is that if you read just about any warranty carefully...anything that can go wrong isn't covered! It relies on a relationship between the dealer and the manufacturer where both parties are concerned for the other. It comes back to two things. What is the difference between a specialty retailer and a mass merchant??? Service is one key we can provide that the mass merchants ignore. Buy your products from manufacturer's that you know will give you the followup support you need. A pretty flame or a price that is $50.00 less means nothing if that support is missing.

Rick Vlahos Creative Classics [email protected]

______________________________________

2.From: [email protected] Date: Fri, 14 Jun 1996 18:08:17 -0400 To: [email protected] Subject: Hpa/Hearth

After reading both press releases, I am confused. Why does the HPA Board feel that it needs to re-invent the wheel? (If it's not broken, why fix it?) If the Hearth Board has not moved fast enough as far as the HPA Staff and Board is concerned, wouldn't it be a good idea to set a time line for both entities to follow that is equitable to both sides? IF there is some other legitimate concern on behalf of the HPA staff and B.O.D., let's hear them. Lets put the real cards on the table and address those points. If it is simply for the reasons listed on the press release, they are not critical enough to abandon a relationship that has worked and worked well for many years. Speaking as someone who has been Certified by Wherf and Hearth for 13 years, I am very dismayed at this turn of events! I would expect the HPA staff and B.O.D. to create a cohesive relationship instead of trying to tear it apart. This industry is fragile enough as is, in-house fighting will cripple us faster.

I truly do not believe HPA needs to be taking on redoing tasks that have been handled by Hearth quite well for many years. Joining forces is one thing, rewriting the book, is ridiculous! I think our dues monies can be much better spent. Now is not the time to start backtracking. To HPA staff, I ask, Where is the firewright program that was supposed to be out last fall, then March, and now may only possibly be out in August?

Hearth Digest 6/18/96

1. Ventless Legal in California


From: [email protected] (John David Crouch) Subject: Re: Hearth Digest 6/13/96 To: [email protected] (Craig Issod)

>June 13,1006 RUMOR: > >I heard that room vented heaters are going to be leagal in California by May >next year. Is there any truth to this? > >Once again, Craig thanks for your efforts. > >Jon

From: John Crouch, HPA, Director of Government Affairs To: Hearth Digest List RE: Vent Free Legeslation in California

The Vent Free Alliance (and it's predisesor organization, the GAMA Vent Free Task Force), have sponsored legeslation in California for the last three sessions, in an attempt to overturn a old law outlawing Vent Free products in this state. The law's roots go back to a history of portable vent free devices, especially in the 1930's, and especially in the LA area.

This year's bill, Senate Bill 798, has had the most success, in fact it passed it's last legeslative hurdle last thursday. It is on it's way to the Governor for his signature.

While the bill does legalize Vent-Free appliances, it does not do so automatically, but rather contains four provisions that all must be met, prior to the sale of these appliances. They are:

1)Department of Housing and Community Development and the Department of Health Services must consider and develop standards for "natural gas unvented decorative gas logs and fireplaces" provided the cost of developing standards does not exceed $145,000.

2) Unvented fireplaces meet the standards developed by these agencies.

3) The California Building Standards Comission adopts the standard as part of the California Building Standards Code.

4) Unvented heaters are listed by an agency approved by Health Services.

5) Installation of the unvented fireplaces must be in accordance with the Cal Building Standards Code.

Another important note is that the legeslative analyst indicated that the agencies estimate that it will cost over $400,000 to develope the standards, yet the bill caps the cost of the regulation at $145,000. This may mean a supplimental appropreation next year, or some other form of funding.

Bottom Line? Even though the bill will proably be signed this month, it is far too early to begin writing orders.

Getting a commercial bill like this passed is always difficult, and the Vent Free Task Force should be commended for this. There is still a lot of work to be done on this issue in this state.

For those of you using AOL, the four points above where almost verbatum from SEN.CA.GOV. I assume this is avalible on the WEB as well.

If any HPA members have questions about this process, I am always avalible to answer questions.

John Crouch [email protected] _____________________________ end of Digest This Month's List Sponsored by LongLeaf Lighter Company Producers of the finest Fatwood Kindling Dealer and distributor Inquiries Welcome Visit our Web Site at http://hearth.com/longleaf


:Hearth Digest 6/19/96

1. HPA Education Director on FIREWRIGHT
2. Note on above


To: [email protected] MIME-Version: 1.0
From: SUSAN KALISH <[email protected]>
Subject: FireWright Training Program Date: Wed, 19 Jun 96 09:55:29 PDT

The expected fulfillment date of the FireWright training program is the beginning of August. Though a delivery date of mid-May was given initially, as HPA's new education director I wanted to ensure that the program met with HPA's and my quality standards. I have been working closely with the parties involved to complete this project - I look forward to getting this exciting product in the hands of hearth product dealers, distributors and manufacturers!

In addition to working with FireWright, I have been working with HPA's Education Committee to develop the educational sessions for EXPO '97, as well as developing ideas for longer term dealer education programs and products. I have been visiting hearth product dealers to talk with them about their needs. Plus, I have been researching resources which will be helpful in the creation of education programs.

The results of the needs assessments conducted at EXPO '96 provided HPA with a superb base of information from which to begin a long term education plan. However, I also welcome your input. If you have suggestions or programs or products, recommendations for speakers or trainers, would like me to visit your location, or would just like to chat, I can be reached at HPA, 703-522-0086. My Internet address at HPA is [email protected].

I look forward to hearing from you. _________________________________________________________________

2. About Firewright (From Craig Issod, [email protected])

Kudos to Susan for her explaination of the status of Firewright..this is the stuff we need to know !

Also, as I understand it, FIREWRIGHT is a very good deal for HPA members, being as it was mostly financed by the Gas Industry (someone correct me if I'm wrong)... I usually don't look a gift horse in the mouth.

After looking a the HPA budget in the last HPA NEWS, I'm surprised at how small their budget really is..the total budget is equal to about the revenues of our two stores ! So, any time they can do more with less, and uphold the correct standards while doing so, I'm for it !


OH ! and one other thing, Susan - maybe you should explain what Firewright is, cause many members (including me) don't know exactly what the deal is !

Subject: Hearth Digest 6/21/96
1. Concern about Unvented in Ca.
2. Advice for the Retailer
3.New Bulletin Board for Communications
4. Firewright Program - Description

1. Concern about Unvented in Ca

From: [email protected] (ward, brad) Subject: unvented

Is anyone else in California concerned about having unvented products? Not because of the mass merchandisers selling them, but from a health stand point? Would any of you have them in your own homes? Around your family? I received a form letter today asking me to write to Governor Wilson to sign SB 794? into law. I wrote a negative letter to the Governor asking him to veto the bill. I ask that all of you who worry about unvented product, from a health stand point, to write to him also. Don't do it because the mass merchants will take sales away, but because in the long run, the product itself will take sales away. Dan Melcom was going to do a story on unvented product and I have yet to see it. I don't know if he didn't have the courage to publish it, I didn't see it, or if the big boys killed it. We have long been a reactive industry, make the sales now and worry about things later. This is one product that, in my opinion, we need to be proactive on. It is a product that will so turn the public against us, as they die from related illnesses, that we may never recover. Will we end-up with the same philosophy as the tobacco? Remember it's not the cigerettes that kills people, it's the cancer and emphysema that kills people. If you would not have these products in your home, you have the opportunity now to stop it from going into less educated people's homes.

___________________________

2. Advice for the Retailer

From: [email protected] (Jonathan A Harman)

I would like to share some advice with all the specialty retailers. I received this advice from someone who I highly respect and has been in the industry for a lot of years.

The advice is so simple you'll probably say " no, duh". I feel it goes hand in hand with the power of the purchase order and is something we all need to remember.

The advice: "If a supplier or manufacturer is not willing to work with you, YOU DON'T NEED THEM".

Simple......."no, duh". I've been applying that advice for the last couple of years and have focused our product line and simplified our operation. I've form stronger ties with the manufacturers and suppliers that want my business (in other words will work with me in all situations) and that have shown their support for the specialty hearth products retailer. This is something we all need to do.

With the above in mind, I would like to publicly thank those suppliers and manufacturers that have gone above and beyond the call of duty:

Everyone in the "Ivory Tower", Travis Industries, everyone at Sunset Fireplace Fixtures, and everyone at Robert H. Peterson. If any of you have problems with these, call them and patch things up. These people have earned and deserve our support.

A special thanks needs to go to the following: NHC, Inc., Mike and Mary at Vermont Castings, Ray and Ursula Oien (the Travis reps), and Vogelzang.

I suppose this is kind of childish, but those people all deserved a public thanking.

To sum this post up: Support those that want the specialty shops business and that make our business lives easier.

Jon, The Hearthside ______________________________

3.New Bulletin Board for Communications

To: [email protected]
From: [email protected]
Subject: HPA & THE FUTURE ... EDI???

North Central Hearth Products Association has started..... in a stumbling attempt....... a web-board where you can share ideas about the future of communications in our industry using some forms of commonality such as EDI or other simple means of saving time and money with simple common sense.... We do not want to monopolize the value of HearthList with just the one subject of communication advances. We will of course keep the List up to date but we do not want to take away from it's many other values with this one all excompassing subject. So NCHPA has donated a web-board for our use.


Did you know that you can request VC price sheets on Excell (which is traslatable to Lotus or almost any spread sheet we might use)...How much data entry time did you just save by requesting that little 3 1/2" PIECE OF PLASTIC?. Majestic/Insta Flame offers their monster price sheets on Excell as well....just for the asking. Plug in your discountfactorsor margins desires and presto its done......And with a little more proding John Davis will get off center and we will begin to see our promised Dura Vent price sheets on 3 1/2" discs in ASCII format...... why ASCII I haven't figured out but I am not complaining....... the translation time will be a lot less than the present entry time....... and that is just a start. If we add up just those dollars of entry time saved>>>>>> (God forbid ...we may save enough money to hire Jonathan Winters again to do somemore talking houses for FireWorks) }:-)

We are not inventing anything new here... infact all we are doing is following the successful tracks of other industries that have begun to benfit from working togther from manufacturer thru distribututor to dealer. Visit http://www.premenos.com. a site just recomended to me by john crouch....... It should blow most of us away..... The means are now begining to be at our deisposal.... it is how we will use them or dispose of them that is important. We have to walk first and remember to bring along as many as we can to keep ourselves strong ...but we must move forward. We may never have our own private sataliye with central contrlled downlinks from manufacturer, to distributioon site to cash register like Wallmart or Sam's Club ..... but we can take some benefits to the bank.

In the next few weeks NCHPA will be sending out a questionaire to its members to better understand the level of computer useage and the computer knowledge and future plans our membership has. We feel it is one of the responsibilities of the NCHPA board to educate our members and improve their computer communications. Our members have asked us to do so and we will follow thru with this promise. We would like to encourage other Affiliates or Associations of HPA to do the same thing with their membership. I would like to collect this data through the NCHPA Web-Board at http://www.weyrkeep.com/wwwboard/wwwboard.html >>> or at http://www.weyrkeep.com/wwwboard/messages/23.html >>>>>>>> I will work that out in the next couple of days....... I HOPE..... Since this web-board site is very new it will have it's share of problems and blunders we will have to fix. Also at this time please remember that the purpose of this site is specific to communication improvement within the HPA, its Affiliates, Associations and members. . The site is presently open to any one that stumbles across it. If this becomes a problem we will set up a security codes to limit access to HPA , Associates and other value added members only. For now we will leave it open to lost hearts in Seatle as well as the brain trusts of Medford.

Ramble on............. Ken Fulgione ____________________________ Visit the Emporium http://www.weyrkeep.com http://www.hearth.com/directfire ___________________________ ~\!|!/~ (Q * ) -----------ooO~(_)~Ooo----------------- ////||\\\\ Dragons Breathe Best Together Forge a Stronger Fire =========================== ____________________________________

4. Firewright Program - Description

To: [email protected] MIME-Version: 1.0
From: SUSAN KALISH <[email protected]>
Subject: FireWright Training Program Date: Fri, 21 Jun 96 09:16:55 PDT

Thanks, Craig, for the opportunity to remind everyone about HPA's FireWright training program.

The program is a training tool consisting of a workbook and accompanying videotape. FireWright was designed to provide fundamental information on installing and troubleshooting gas hearth appliances. The workbook is filled with illustrations, color photos and charts about gas hearth products and explains the issues related to installing and troubleshooting the appliances. The videotape mirrors the information provided in the workbook, showing the actual operation of the appliances, and reinforcing the material covered in the workbook. The training program can be used as a self-study program or in a classroom setting.

FireWright represents HPA's first step toward the goal of increasing the technical knowledge level of hearth industry technicians in order to make installation and service personnel more competitive in today's market.

HPA has a wonderful brochure which describes the program and includes an order form. I plan a mailing of the brochure shortly. The instructions and mailing labels for those who placed their orders previously have already been prepared, so as soon as the books and tapes are delivered the orders will be filled.

Please contact me if you have any questions.

____________________________________________ Send Posts to [email protected]

end of digest


This Month's List Sponsored by LongLeaf Lighter Company Producers of the finest Fatwood Kindling Dealer and distributor Inquiries Welcome Visit our Web Site at http://hearth.com/longleaf

Hearth Digest 6/22/96
1. Comment on EDI, Communication, Bulletin Boards, etc.
2. Will not Sell Ventless



1. Comment on EDI, Communication, Bulletin Boards, etc.Craig Issod ([email protected]) says:

> [email protected] said:

>North Central Hearth Products Association has started..... in a stumbling >attempt....... a web-board where you can share ideas about the future of >communications in our industry using some forms of commonality such as EDI

Craig Issod adds : From the reading I do, it appears that the original concept of EDI will be superceded by the internet. That is, the same electronic data exchange services will cost much less to do over the internet .. and give the companies more complete control over the process. The dealer will not have to dial a seperate phone number...just hook right in over a TCP connection.

For instance, a hearth manufacturer could easily set up a web site (with limited access) that customers could

1. Check inventory
2. Check status of orders
3. Place orders
4. Download documents, price list, manuals
5. Find answers to service questions

and much more. Check out Federal Express or UPS's site...yes, they know exactly where your package is ! - quite a deal for a few bucks shipping charges...!

Also, I've considered setting up a number of Bulletin Boards, but am concerned that the online "hearth" population is still too small...Without enough participants, a good dialog will be tough. I envision replacing this list someday with a group of bulletin boards...each with different topics. We will need aprox. 1000 online members to do a good job at this. Also the BB's must be a lot more "user friendly" than much of the current crop...please check out "The Salon" for a model which I intend to use for the boards....http://eweb06.online.apple.com/webx - By the way, this site is running on a Macintosh WWW server....

2. Will not Sell Ventless

From: [email protected] Date: Fri, 21 Jun 1996 17:32:54 -0400 To: [email protected] Subject: Re: Hearth Digest 6/21/96

In a message dated 96-06-21 15:38:08 EDT, you write:

>1. Concern about Unvented in Ca

I would have to agree with Brad. In my opinion ANYTHING that burns should be vented outside. Every time I have slept in a house with gas heat I wake up feeling lousy..headache, etc...and these are vented systems with no spillage and I have had a humidifier going. The "experts" can say all they want about unvented ..how safe it is ..blah blah blah...They will NEVER be installed in my home and, if I can help it, in any of my customers homes. If my opinion puts me on someone's black list so be it! My consolation will be the number of my customers and would be customers whose lives I have saved. FLAME AWAY!

Phil Mace The Lucky Sweeps

Send Posts to [email protected]

end of digest


Hearth Digest 6/22/96
In this issue:

1. Good Things about Ventless
2. Flame wars ?

1. In a message dated 96-06-21 15:38:08 EDT, > [email protected] mwrites: > > >1. Concern about Unvented in Ca > > I would have to agree with Brad. In my opinion ANYTHING that burns should be > vented outside. Every time I have slept in a house with gas heat I wake up > feeling lousy..headache, etc...and these are vented systems with no spillage > and I have had a humidifier going. The "experts" can say all they want about > unvented ..how safe it is ..blah blah blah...They will NEVER be installed in > my home and, if I can help it, in any of my customers homes. If my opinion > puts me on someone's black list so be it! My consolation will be the number > of my customers and would be customers whose lives I have saved. FLAME AWAY! > > Phil Mace > The Lucky Sweeps


[email protected] replies:

I have sold unvented product in Texas for the past 12 years, and my father has been associated with the unvented space heater industry since 1964. We have used unvented space heaters in our homes for virtually all of our lives, and never had a problem. We primarily use them as suplementary heat in those areas where central heating is not too effective (ie - add on rooms, rooms with two or three walls exposed to the outside, etc). I have sold thousands of unvented space heaters and have never had a single problem. My days date back to before ODS (oxygen depletion sensors) were required, but I do think that ODS are a positive addition to unvented product (even though I never experienced problems with unvented heaters in days prior to ODS). Current ODS equipped space heaters and gas logs produce very low levels of noxious fumes...if you can smell them or feel the effects, you either are not using them correctly, or have a defective product. Instructions tell you to allow one square inch of ventilation for every 1,000 btu of your product (a 20,000 btu heater requires a 20" wide window to be cracked 1"). In Texas, where houses (for the most part) are not air tight, we feel no effects without cracking a window. I am not trying to convince those of you who have made up your minds about unvented product to try them...I realize that it would be an effort in vein, however those of you who have never experienced unvented products first hand should refrain from flaming a product which you obviously know very little about. My positive experiences have taught me that unvented products are not only safe, but an affordable way for lower income families to heat their homes. To many of us, unvented products are a large portion of our sales. Our customers in vented products are primarily middle to upper income, but unvented customers are from all income groups. We enjoy the ability to offer quality products to all income groups, not just middle to upper income families. FOR THE RECORD, I use a Rinnai Tropic vent free gas space heater in my den and I enjoy it. I have four (soon to be five) children, and have no problem with it. I will continue using, selling, and promoting the wonderful quality vent-free products on the market today. I would like to add that I test all products I sell, and do not use a lot of "johnny come lately" vent free products until I know first hand that the manufacturer has taken the time to learn how to make safe, quality products. I will list the products that I know first hand are safe, quality products for those interested. I will also forward the manufacturers phone numbers to any interested dealers.

Rinnai Gas Space Heaters Vanguard (Desa International) space heaters and logs Martin Industries gas space heaters and logs The Dearborn Co. gas space heaters and logs

All of the above companies have been in the business of providing quality space heaters and gas logs for many years and in my opinion are the best. (Above list not in any particular order)

Sincerely,

Bob Rooke President, FT. Worth Hearth & Home, Inc.

Not affiliated with any of the above manufacturers except as a dealer. And PROUD to be!

[email protected]


2. Flame wars ?

Craig Issod ([email protected]) says: OK, we've heard both sides of the story about unvented. As usual, the truth probably lies somewhere in between. While folks are not dropping dead from unvented, we cannot say that there have been no problems either. In fact, one of the companies mentioned told me they have a department that concerns themselves with nothing more than settling unvented claims (soot damage, repainting, etc.)... Other dealers and companies have also told me that problems are occuring in the field. Of course, problems occur with vented units also (I have had some) and with direct vents, etc.

So, my goal is to keep this forum as informational as possible, and to avoid "flame wars" and other such exchanges...mind you, neither of the posts above are "flames", but if a number of responses THAT CONTAINED LITTLE OR NO FACTS showed up, I might hesitate to post them.

So, when posting, please try to present both facts and opinion that would be of use to all the readers of the list.

And, if you really want to flame someone..email then directly !

_____________________________________________________ Send Posts to [email protected]

end of digest


Hearth Digest 6/24/96 C
IN this issue:
1. Efforts on gas safety


To: [email protected] From: [email protected] Subject: Explosion

Just remember Mr. Hearth Shop People ..... we are not alone out there. Some efforts are being made and some disasters are still afoot.... The following is just a copy of some talk over the local Chimney Sweeps List. It seems we all share the rush to market problems in the field. The manufacturers will clean it up as we make them pay for the repairs we need to service and by our refusal to promote unsafe product.

>From: GRANT DARROW <[email protected]> >Subject: Explosion >To: Multiple recipients of list CHIMNEYS-L

>Just got back from three days up at Alladin Steel products (Quadrafire) >going over new products, in particular gas. Its great having free access to >the entire crew from Nick and Dan in the lab down to the guy that cuts the >firebrick for their wood stoves in the plant. > >Dan and Nick blew up a gas stove for us while we where there, which resulted >in shrapnel embedded in the doors and walls and blew the cap 20 some feet >into the air ripping a hole in the insulation at the ceiling. They video >taped this in slow motion the day we got there. > >What these guys demostrated is what can happen with a Direct vent gas stove >when there isn't an explosion door in the stove design, slow drop out time >and a homeowner that hits the igniter with out purging the stove. > >During my service calls this year I've been clocking the drop out time on >the gas stoves I encounter, in particular some of my competitor's, sorry I >can't mention names. I've been alarmed at drop out times of up to 4 and a >half minutes!!! For those of you not framiliar with this, drop out is when a >gas valve shutsoff the flow of gas after the pilot light is extinguished. >Until it drops out the pilot is spilling gas into the stove. > >Valve manufacturers generally specify drop out within a millivolt range of >say 120-30mv. However, thermopiles can store up enough heat to continue to >generate 30 mv for an awful long time. people like David Pomeroy say 2-3 >minutes is normal, but 4 1/2 minutes!! > >An explosion door is simply a weighted door which will open and relieve >pressure in the event of an explosion. Dan and Nick clamped the explosion >doors shut and plugged the exhaust vent. They lit the stove and allowed it >to run until the flame lifted off the burner and extinguished itself. After >about 30 seconds they snapped the piezo simulating a homeowner trying to >relit the stove. BAM!!! > >The major point Dan was making is the importance of following the >manufacturers venting instructions. Improperly installed Direct vent will >cause flame lift and shut down and improperly built stoves are bombs. > >You Folks out east are going to see gas coming in over the next 5years like >and invading horde of nomads out of the west, the US gas market is the >largest in the world and is being targeted by gas appliance companies all >over the world. One foriegn manufacturer saw an 80% increase in gas >appliance sales in the Pacific Northwest in one year!! > >willieweep > > alias g darrow

____________________________ Visit the Emporium http://www.weyrkeep.com http://www.hearth.com/directfire ___________________________ ~\!|!/~ (Q * ) -----------ooO~(_)~Ooo----------------- ////||\\\\ Dragons Breathe Best Together Forge a Stronger Fire ===========================

Send Posts to [email protected]

end of digest


Hearth Digest 6/26/96

In this issue:

1. QuadraFire cleaner than ever ..
2. Direct Sales on the NET
3. Comment on direct sales

1. QuadraFire cleaner than ever ..

From: Quadrafire <[email protected]> Organization: Aladdin Steel Products Subject: Quadrafire retestin

Good news from Quadrafire

As some of you might know, our 4300 series wood stove was recently involved in a scandal involving falsification of test report numbers along with six other manufactures. Since the validity of our grams per hour rating was in question, we were required to retest the stove to confirm our original 2.5 grams per hour rating.

Well, the good news is: not only did the 4300 meet the original rating, it BEAT IT!!! We are proud to announce that the Quadrafire 4300 series wood burning appliances will be rated at 2.1 grams per hour, one of the cleanest in the industry.

These figures confirm what most of you already know- We thank you for your patience during this retesting period, and hope that these results strengthen your confidence in Aladdin Steel Products,Inc. and our Quadrafire line of hearth appliances.

Aladdin Steel Prod., Inc.

2. Direct Sales on the Net

From: Roger Sanders <[email protected]> MIME-Version: 1.0 To: Craig Issod <[email protected]> Subject: Direct sales over the net

How about bringing back an old issue with some new information that hearth web surfers will interested in. The issue is: How should the hearth industry handle hearth sales over the internet?

The Ducane Company, a leading BBQ manufacturer has resolved the problem for them. They have just said, in effect, that the internet cannot be used to direct sell Ducanes because there is no way to properly maintain, support and service their BBQs if uncontrolled sales go on into areas by dealers discounting BBQs into other areas where those dealers don't have to provide the service and warranty support.

They specifically said on June 25,1996 to their distributors about retailer internet direct sales that: "This affects the good name of Ducane and undermines the service and warranty responsibilities you have as a distributor and are compensated for through your margins."

Ducane says that they will terminate distributor relationships if their distributors do not control their dealers. If a dealer does not comply, the distributor is directed to "discontinue shipping to him".

This might be the best policy for hearth appliance manufacturers to follow. God only knows that we have 10 times the service and warranty problems with stoves than with BBQs.

How about it you stove manufacturers, will you support and control your retailer network like Ducane is doing?

_______________________________

3. Comment on Direct Sales (above)

Craig Issod ([email protected]) says:

Over the past year, both myself and some of my clients have experimented with direct sales on the internet. A lot of information was gotten from these test markets..but the summary is: It surely COULD be done profitably. Not that any tom,dick or harry could do it, it would take some marketing muscle and savvy, but the model is there. If anyone wants more info on these models, email me personally.

Many firms, such as Lehmans, Plow and Hearth and Real Goods are already selling hearth products by Direct Mail, and their customers are satisfied. What is the difference on the Internet? The Hearth Business started with direct mail (VC) , continued (CDW), and at this point in time probably has a LACK of direct marketing. I have often thought of going "big time" into the mail-order hearth business, but I'm too conservative to blow a couple hundred grand getting started.

Either way, I don't think that direct mail or net sales of hearth products represent a valid threat to retail stores. Software, Audio CD's, etc...are being sold by the millions if $$ on the net, but our business does not translate as well to the net.

Maybe when we can display full-motion video of the different gas logs burnings, and then refer the customers (by videophone) to their local installer (grin) !

I do appreciate hearing the input of how manufacturers feel about such efforts. Travis, for instance, has suggested that they frown upon direct net sales.....they feel their dealer base is valuable and strong... I respect their views, and as a dealer will not "push" their product on the net FOR DIRECT SALES. I still feature it on my site, and have gotten local (and a bit extended) sales from it. After all, I'm old fashioned - if it's not a win-win situation, I'm not into it.

I like this suggestion much better than the FORCE approach that Ducane has choosen. I even doubt that Ducanes edict would stand up to the law..if taken that far. ____________________________________________________________________________________ Send Posts to [email protected]

end of digest


Hearth Digest 6/29/96
1.Suggested Purchase order Boilerplate ?
2. VC/CFM Article/Hearth and Home

1. Suggested Purchase order Boilerplate ?

From: Roger Sanders <[email protected]> MIME-Version: 1.0 To: Craig Issod <[email protected]> Subject: Questionare

Here's a proposed questionare for the HearthNet. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- PROPOSED HEARTH RETAILER QUESTIONARE

CURRENT HEARTH RETAILER PURCHASE ORDERS PROVIDE NO RECOURSE AT ALL IF PROBLEMS CAUSED BY THE MANUFACTURER DEVELOP IN ORDERING, SHIPPING, INSTALLING OR OPERATING THEIR PRODUCTS. SHOULD OUR PURCHASE ORDERS INCLUDE "BOILERPLATE" TERMS AND CONDITIONS THAT GIVE HEARTH RETAILERS SPECIFIC RIGHTS, IF PROBLEMS DEVELOP? (THE BOILERPLATE WOULD HAVE TO TAKE PRECIDENCE OVER ANY "DEALER AGREEMENTS") IF SO, SHOULD THE FOLLOWING ISSUES BE ADDRESSED IN THE "BOILERPLATE" WORDING TO GIVE HEARTH RETAILERS RECOURSE?

DEALERSHIP NAME _______________________________

1. Multiple service calls where service personnel can't fix the problems and the manufacturer doesn't have the solution. Yes ____ No _____

2. Replacement of a "lemon" appliance in order to keep the customer happy. Who should pay for the replacement stove? Who should take the loss on sale of the used stove (if sellable) ? Yes ____ No ___

3. Hidden freight damage (defective packaging design) that freight companys will not cover because it was in the warehouse for a few months before careful inspection. Yes ____ No _____

4. Warranty Claims that don't get processed within 30 days. Questions aren't asked by the manufacturer until several months after work was done. Warranty claims that aren't applied to dealer's account, even though they were "approved". Yes ____ No _____

5. Coop that doesn't get processed within 30 days. Credits that don't get applied to the account even though the Coop was approved. Yes ____ No _____

6. Purchase Orders that are given to manufacturers and are then never acknowledged as have been received. Yes ____ No _____

7. Purchase Orders that are given to manufacturers, but their shipping dates are never acknowledged. This makes it impossible to schedule installations unless dealers significantly increase inventory to always have every version on hand. Yes ____ No _____

8. Back Orders that have no projected delivery dates. Yes ____ No _____

9. Design defects that are not considered a warranty problem because there are no defects in materials or workmanship. Yes ____ No _____

10. Unavailable (or long delivery schedule) replacement parts for failed appliances . Yes ____ No _____

11. Lack of manufacturer Part Numbers on appliances, accessories and parts. Yes ____ No _____

12. Shipments received without invoices included and without reference to the P.O. Yes ____ No _____

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2. VC/CFM Article/Hearth and Home (From Craig [email protected])

Received my new Hearth and Home and noticed a special full page article on the VC/CFM thing. Seems like this subject is shaking up the industry big time, and affecting many other parties other than myself.

Every call I make to fellow retailers, consultants, reps and others seems to drift to this as the "Subject of the Year". Truthfully, no one knows what to make of all this. There seem to be sooo.. many inconsistencies - Vc dealers continue to quote Dennis and Bill as saying "Nothing will change" at the HPA meeting, and then point to massive changes as soon as the ink has dried on the deal.

Some of most business savvy folks I know say "No way this thing will work in the long run" - They tell me "There is no precedent for this type of activity - it's bad business to burn ALL your bridges behind you as you go into the future".

I have to reluctantly agree. Simply speaking (for you hippies out there), the vibes (vibrations) are bad ! Usually, when something doesn't feel good and right - it isn't.

Of course, I am personally involved in this. My rep called me the other day, gave me a "dear craig" story and told me that he was opening another "full-line" VC dealer 9 miles from my main store. He told me not to take it personally - "t's only business" - I told him I WAS taking it personal.

So, my rep has called me twice in the past two months, both times to tell me about opening new business near me. He's also indicated that he's been driving around my store (to meet with these other accounts and gauge the distance) - and he never even stopped in to visit us !

You see, our store is a bit different than the "Mom and Pop" operations that CFM thinks are history. We have long term employees that have Health Insurance, Profit Sharing Plans, Real World salaries, paid vacations, company vehicles and families to support. These managers take EVERYTHING personally cause they have not yet made their millions from stock deals !

Vermont Castings and CFM will not even see a blimp on their sales chart if we sell double the product we sell now, or if we sell none. VC is currently about 20-25% of our business. If they had played their cards right, they could have increased this to 35-40%. Given their current direction, it's hard to see how they will earn more of our business...but then again, I don't really think they want it.

We are doing a massive remodeling of our showrooms this summer, and expanding one store into a larger area. We will sell more hearth product this season than ever before - I'm certain of it.

Dealers don't care what VC's market cap is, they don't care what it's "debt to equity" ratio is, they just want to be dealt with in an honest, straightforward and consistent fashion...perhaps this is asking too much......

As my GM told me "He's not Happy"

Craig Issod Stoveworks Inc. ________________________________________________________________

Send Posts to [email protected]

end of digest


This Month's List Sponsored by LongLeaf Lighter Company Producers of the finest Fatwood Kindling Dealer and distributor Inquiries Welcome Visit our Web Site at http://hearth.com/longleaf From ???@??? Sun Jun 30 15:43:35 1996 To: comp From: [email protected] (Craig Issod) Subject: Hearth Digest 6/30/96 Cc: Bcc: main X-Attachments: Message-Id: <v01530500adfc95aa510d@[207.8.144.22]>

In this digest:
1. Answers about Proposed Purchase Order text
2. Comment on Bulletin Boards


1. Answers about Proposed Purchase Order text

From: Jim Butchart <[email protected]> Organization: Hearth & Color Shop MIME-Version: 1.0 To: hearthlist <[email protected]> Subject: Re: Hearth Digest 6/29/96

Roger Sanders wrote: >

> PROPOSED HEARTH RETAILER QUESTIONARE >

Regarding the "purchase order boiler plate": You could save a whole lot of time and expense in developing this idea by just sending your vendor a letter stating you don't want to do business with them anymore. I don't see how or why any company would agree to sell anything to you with those "demands" listed on your purchase order. If you have those issues with a vendor it is time to shop elsewhere anyway. -- Jim Butchart [email protected] "Do or do not. There is no try" - Yoda http://www.HearthShop.com ______________________________________________________

From: [email protected] Date: Sat, 29 Jun 1996 23:18:22 -0400

Subject: Re: Hearth Digest 6/29/96

Hi Guys!

Just wanted to say that the companies you are talking about are making business decistions. There's no reason why you can't do the same. Become boutique. It works. I spend maybe 5 times as much on hair care products as many people. It's because the people I buy them from are professionals, and I value their products over what I could buy at any other store

Tah! _______________________________________________________

From: "John Wallace" <[email protected]> To: List Subject: RE: Purchase Orders

As a small dealer some of the issues don't apply. However I think these are problems that need to be talked about. The biggest issues for our store would be, warranty claims and design defects.


________________________________________________________

2. Comment on Bulletin Boards

From: "John Wallace" <[email protected]> To: "Craig Issod" <[email protected]> Subject: RE: BB's

Ken Fulgione said:

>http://www.weyrkeep.com/wwwboard/messages/23.html...... > >North Central Hearth Products Association has started..... in a stumbling >attempt....... a web-board where you can share ideas about the future of >communications in our industry

Regarding New Bulletin Board for Communications. For the past 17 yrs. I have been told that I was the only dealer having that type of problem. Not really but it seamed that way at times. With Craig starting the HearthNet, and others now starting BBs we have a way to communicate with each other on a daily basis, not just at meetings. This allows us to exchange views on subjects that need to be talked about. This is a forum that all HPA dealers and manufacturers should take advantage of....John Wallace ___________________________________________________________ Send Posts to [email protected]

end of digest

Back to List archives - Back to Club House